
Relations between Brussels and Moscow have reached a point of difficult return with the Navalni case. The foreign ministers of the European Union, meeting this Monday in Brussels, have agreed to extend the sanctions initiated against Russia in 2014 as punishment for the persecution and imprisonment of the Russian opponent Alexei Navalni. But they have also decided for the first time to embark on a strategy of counterattack and containment against a regime of Vladimir Putin that “unfortunately, has opted for permanent confrontation and has decided to become an adversary,” as pointed out by the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Policy, Josep Borrell.
The turbulences in the relationship with Russia have contrasted with the new climate of harmony with Washington, which has become evident during the first high-level meeting with the Administration of US President Joe Biden. The US Secretary of State, Antony Blinken, participated for two hours, by videoconference, in the Council of EU Foreign Ministers. Borrell has assured that Blinken’s intervention “has touched my heart, beyond politics” and trusts in a renewed transatlantic understanding after the cooling of the four years of Donald Trump.
With Russia, on the other hand, the gap is widening almost by the day. The new sanctions agreed on Monday will result in a list of high-ranking officials who participated in the persecution and imprisonment of Navalni. And they will be applied on the basis of the new sanctions regime for human rights violations adopted by the EU at the end of last year. The decision, which should be officially finalized in the coming days, comes after the recent head-on clash in Moscow between Borrell and Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov over the imprisonment of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalni and the repression of some of his supporters.
Borrell has assured at the end of the meeting that the ministers have given him their support after a trip that provoked Lavrov’s wrath following the demand for Navalni’s release raised by the High Representative. “I did not go to Moscow because I felt like it but because I had a mandate from the foreign ministers,” Borrell recalled.
The High Representative said he was convinced that his trip to the Russian capital had helped the 27 member states to unify their views on Russia, usually divided between partners in favor of an iron fist (such as Poland) and those who prefer to appease Moscow (such as France and Germany). “There is a shared feeling that Russia is sliding down an authoritarian drift and moving away from Europe,” Borrell concluded after the meeting.
Borrell believes that his clash with Lavrov in Moscow has served to visualize that Russia “is not interested in cooperation but in confrontation and distancing.” The High Representative, after the meeting with the ministers, pointed out that “we must find a modus vivendi with a neighbor that, unfortunately, has opted for permanent confrontation and has decided to become an adversary”.
The agreement reached clears the way for a new round of sanctions. And it illustrates the increasingly deteriorating relationship between Brussels and Moscow. In addition to the trade sanctions imposed for Russian aggression against the territorial integrity of Ukraine, the EU has already banned the entry and ordered the freezing of their assets on EU territory of more than 180 high-ranking officials of the Russian administration. The list will now be expanded with another list of names based on the new instrument of sanctions for human rights violations.
The punishment, however, is more symbolic than real, which contrasts with Borrell’s harsh words at the end of the Council of Foreign Ministers. The additional list of a handful of names (less than a dozen are being considered) seems to make little impression on the Kremlin hierarchs. Just this Monday, the Russian ambassador to the EU, Vladimir Chizhov, has underestimated in an interview what he called “a new round of illegitimate and unilateral restrictive measures against Russia”. According to the diplomat, they cannot be called sanctions because sanctions “are the exclusive prerogative of the UN Security Council.”
Most European partners are alarmed by what they see as an authoritarian and aggressive drift of the current Russian president. But the major capitals, with Berlin at the forefront, advocate a very gradual response that in no case jeopardizes bilateral relations with the neighboring country. The partners that feel more vulnerable, such as Poland and the Baltic countries, advocate instead a forceful response that would keep Moscow’s extraterritorial temptations at bay.
The EU-27 have opted for a middle way, closer to Berlin’s postulates, but which paves the way for a possible hardening of relations with Moscow. For the time being, they will apply a selective punishment concentrated on a handful of high-ranking Russian officials who can be proven to be linked to Navalni’s imprisonment and a violation of human rights.
The sanctions regime for human rights violations was approved last December and allows for the punishment of individual perpetrators of alleged violations. The mechanism, which emulates the so-called Magnitsky Act of the USA, seeks to focus punishment on specific individuals without the need to establish a sanctions regime against their country of origin.
This is the fourth sanctions regime applied to Russia since 2014, when economic retaliation was enacted for the occupation and annexation of the Ukrainian territory of Crimea. In 2019, the EU premiered with Russian and Syrian officials its new sanctions regime for chemical weapons attacks, also wielded at the end of last year to punish the poisoning of Navalni. And in 2020, the EU also premiered its cyber-attack sanctions regime with Russia.
Brussels insists that sanctions are not an end in themselves, but a tool to change the behavior or practices of the punished country. But in the case of Russia, repeated EU reprisals have so far failed to change one iota the international policy of its president, Vladimir Putin, whom Brussels blames for interference in Western democratic processes, attacks with chemical weapons on EU territory, harassment of neighboring countries (such as Ukraine or Georgia) and military interventions in conflicts such as those in Syria or Libya.
Venezuela
European foreign ministers also agreed on Monday to extend the list of sanctions against the regime of Nicolás Maduro in Venezuela following the elections to the National Assembly on December 6. The EU has added another 19 high-ranking Venezuelan officials to the list of people banned from entering the 27 member states and whose assets in European territory must be frozen. The punishment, according to the ministers, is due to the fact that these officials undermined the democratic rights of the Venezuelan opposition in elections which, according to Brussels, did not meet minimum standards of plurality and transparency.
The new sanctions bring to 55 the number of Venezuelan authorities on the list. The EU began adopting restrictive measures against the Maduro regime in 2017. Those sanctioned on Monday include, among others, a vice president of the Venezuelan government, two deputies, a provincial governor, six Supreme Court magistrates, members of the National Electoral Council and four high-ranking military officers.
