
A federal commission gave its preliminary approval to the president’s project this Thursday donald trump to build a monumental arch that would transform Washington’s skyline, although he postponed a key decision on whether the work must comply with federal law limiting building heights.
Despite widespread public opposition, The National Capital Planning Commission voted to approve preliminary plans for the 250-foot-tall structurewhich Trump proposes to erect in a roundabout located at the Virginia end of the Memorial Bridge, heading towards Washington.
The initiative is part of the projects promoted by the president to remodel different spaces in the American capital.
The staff technical report recommended approving the proposal, but with modifications to align it with the Building Height Law, including redistributing the height of the arch, the observation deck and the statues planned at the top.
However, commission members decided to postpone the analysis of whether that legislation applies to the project.
Committee Chairman Will Scharf noted that the Department of the Interior, responsible for the project, presented a legal analysis arguing that the law would not be binding on the federal government.
“My opinion is that, for now, we are only considering preliminary approval of the project and that the discussion on the applicability of the Building Height Law can wait, at least, until our next meeting,” Scharf said.
Eight of the twelve commissioners voted in favor of preliminary approval, one voted against and three abstained.
Scharf indicated that the final vote could be held in September.
During the hearing, the commission heard recommendations from staff and arguments from dozens of citizens registered to express their position on the proposal.
While the meeting was taking place, work continued at the White House to build the new ballroom promoted by Trump, a project valued at $400 million.
Criticisms of the project
Among the opponents, several questioned that the arch was built next to Arlington National Cemetery, considering that it distorted the solemn character of the place.
Vietnam veteran and architectural historian Michael Lemmon, one of the plaintiffs seeking to stop the project in court, argued that the work represents a lack of respect for those who rest in that cemetery.
“As a war veteran, I feel the duty to protect the memory and honor the sacrifice of my companions and all those who rest there. This monumental and pretentious arch does not fulfill either of those two functions,” he said.
Other participants pointed out that monuments such as the one dedicated to Vietnam veterans, that of World War II veterans and that of Martin Luther King Jr. were the result of long consultation and planning processes, which is why they asked for a broader analysis before approving this new work.
Concerns were also raised about the impact on traffic, pedestrian safety and the visual effect of the arch, which would be more than twice the height of the Lincoln Memorial, at 99 feet, and nearly half that of the Washington Monument, at 555 feet.
Some opponents also argued that Congress should expressly authorize construction, an interpretation that Trump rejects.
No defined budget
The U.S. Commission of Fine Arts approved the arch’s design in May and the National Capital Planning Commission began evaluating it in June.
Although Trump said last year that the work could be financed with private donations originally intended for the new White House ballroom, the administration has not released a budget for the project and it is expected to also receive public funds.
