Federal Prosecutor defends accusations against banker for trying to bribe Governor Pedro Pierluisi

Federal Prosecutor defends accusations against banker for trying to bribe Governor Pedro Pierluisi

The federal prosecutor’s office defended the charges filed against banker Julio Herrera Velutini for allegedly trying to bribe Governor Pedro Pierluisi so that the Office of Financial Institutions (OCIF) would stop an intervention with his bank.

The defense of Herrera Velutini, who is also accused of another bribery scheme with former governor Wanda Vazquez Garced, asked the federal court this month to dismiss three charges related to an alleged attempt to bribe Pierluisi to benefit Bancredito International Bank & Trust, Corp.

On the motion of his lawyers, the banker stressed that his contributions to the electoral campaigns of Vazquez Garced and Pierlusi were “legal”but that the Public Ministry has tried to “criminalize” them.

When requesting the dismissal of counts five and six of the accusation against Herrera Velutini, the defense recounted that the Public Ministry “targeted Herrera through an undercover operation” to produce “allegations that are no better than his claims related to the alleged contributions to Governor Vazquez and, consequently, must be dismissed in their entirety.”

He denounced that the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) “interfered for years” with the operations of his bank, including “clandestine intervention and the subversion of privileged relationships with the bank’s lawyers who were negotiating with the Office of the Commissioner of Financial Institutions of Puerto Rico.”

The defense alleged that, “recognizing that Herrera did not engage in criminal activity with Governor Vazquez,” the “The FBI finally resorted to participating in a five-month sting operation, tasking Joseph Fuentes, a confidential informant who committed crimes related to” electoral campaigns.

In August of last year, Fuentes was sentenced to one year and two months in prison for participating in a scheme to hide the identities of contributors to the Pierluisi campaign through a political action committee, known as the “PAC Salvemos a Puerto Rico.”

That case revealed that Fuentes acted as an undercover cooperator for the authorities, although he tried to obstruct the investigation by leaking its content to other defendants. In his motion, Herrera Velutini’s defense highlighted Fuentes’ “misconduct” as an FBI informant.

“The fact that Fuentes has repeatedly engaged in this conduct, but that he continues to be the axis of the statements of the Public Ministry, calls into question the totality of the allegations raised in the accusation,” argued the motion. of the defense of Herrera Velutini, signed by the lawyers Sonia I. Torres Pabon and Lilly Ann Sanchez, and the lawyers Marc E. Kasowitz, Jason M. Short and Robin Rathmell.

The lawyers claimed that the FBI “designed” the operation that led Fuentes “to pose as a person with access to Governor Pierluisi and make repeated and unsolicited proposals to representatives of the bank” with “false representation that it could assist the bank in the negotiations with OCIF”.

“In doing so, Fuentes solicited contributions not to Governor Pierluisi, but to an independent spending committee (a ‘Super PAC’) that Fuentes controlled,” the defense attorneys said.

“As with previous efforts, the FBI’s five-month sting operation ultimately failed,” he added. “Even so, the Public Ministry presented the charges against Herrera.”

According to his motion, charge number five against Herrera Velutini accuses him of participating in a conspiracy with political adviser john blakeman and the then president of Bancredito, Frances Diazto “offer and receive a bribe to Governor Pierluisi”, in the form of a campaign contribution, in exchange for him using his influence to “secure a favorable outcome” in the OCIF investigation against his bank.

Counts six and seven, related to wire fraud, are contingent on count five being proven.

The defense lawyers maintain that “the accusatory document fails to allege a ‘quid pro quo’ agreement between the banker and Governor Pierluisi,” who assured in August 2022 that he was unaware of Fuentes’ illegal actions.

They argued that Pierluisi, as the only public official in the bribery and fraud scheme, was “the only person who could have manifested the mutual understanding required for the exchange of money for the favor,” but the governor “was completely oblivious to Fuentes’ actions and representations.”

Likewise, they pointed out, the indictment does not allege that Fuentes “ever met or at least spoke with Herrera or that Herrera ever requested that something of value be provided to Governor Pierluisi.”

In addition, in the same motion, the banker’s defense argued that campaign contributions “are constitutionally protected as freedom of expression.”

Meanwhile, they argued that judicial precedents have established that in order to prove a bribery scheme with campaign contributions, it is necessary to prove that it was with an “explicit and contemporaneous agreement, between the donor and the public official”, and that the action was controlled by the contribution.

The motion cites the content of communications, at different times in 2021, between Fuentes, Blakeman and Diaz, as well as Diaz with Herrera Velutini. The lawyers argued that none of their communications prove any violation of law and offered explanations for each, including their frustration with OCIF.

The “allegations in counts 5 to 7 constitute a mere recitation of a timeline of events, devised by the FBI and, in large part, led by persons other than Herrera or Governor Pierluisi, culminating in a completely lawful campaign donation,” the defense stated.

According to the indictment, Herrera Velutini’s donation to the PAC was $25,000.

US attorney asks jury to decide

For its part, the federal prosecutor’s office requested that the defense’s motion be dismissed and argued that a jury should decide the case.

The “allegations of the indictment establish an explicit ‘quid pro quo’ bribery scheme,” sustained a motion signed by the federal prosecutor Ryan R Crosswellof the Public Integrity Division of the United States Department of Justice.

It indicated that the three charges expose “sufficient essential facts for the alleged offenses.”

In addition, he pointed out that judicial precedents establish that bribes “need to have explicit terms, but they do not have to be expressly stated.” But, even so, Crosswell assured that, in this case, the charges “allege that the terms of the bribe were both explicit and express.”

Given the argument that Herrera Velutini “never reached an agreement with any public official ‘to pay or receive a bribe,'” the prosecutor recalled that the text of charge 5 of the statement “accuses him of conspiring with others to bribe a public official, without reaching an agreement directly with the public official himself.”

According to the prosecutor, Herrera Velutini challenges the allegations “by offering alternative and innocent explanations, but the First Circuit (of Appeals) has admonished its district courts not to engage in such a paragraph-by-paragraph analysis of the indictments to decide on motions to dismiss.”

“Herrera is free to present himself as an unfortunate victim of circumstance, but he must do so before a jury,” Crosswell said.

“Herrera is wrong in law and wrong in fact. The Public Ministry respectfully requests that his motion to dismiss be denied,” he added.

Previously, Herrera Velutini and co-defendant Mark Rossini had joined the request to dismiss counts 1, 2 and 4 that they share with Vazquez Garced.

Before the alleged bribery attempt through Pierluisi’s electoral campaign, the indictment alleges that Herrera Velutini made contributions to the then-governor’s primarista campaign to replace the person in charge of OCIF with someone who would end the intervention for alleged irregularities in Bancredito.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!