Some conflictive ties between siblings go back to childhood, others wake up suddenly in adulthood; In some cases it becomes normal and daily treatment between the brothers and in others, it drives them away forever.
William and Harry Windsor following the young prince’s renunciation of his royal title; the strong media fights between Liam and Noel Gallagher; Olivia De Havilland and Joan Fontaine, two actress sisters who became estranged after competing in the same Oscar shortlist for best actress in 1942; Mary and Anne Boleyn, two young women competing in their goal to be the wife of King Henry VIII. From historical figures to stars of the show, athletes and unknown citizens… the list could be endless.
Fights between siblings are an expected behavior that arises from the second year of life in children.. They start out being physical and with time and their maturation, they become more sophisticated.
Professionals call dangerous conflicts between adult siblings; Evidence of this is research that was published in 2020 in the Journal of Family Psychology in which specialists conclude that conflict between older siblings was linked, in part, to symptoms of depression, anxiety, hostility, and loneliness; while siblings with harmonious bonds tended to reflect more signs of personal well-being.
Carolina Moche, a graduate in Psychology, agrees with the latter and adds: “undoubtedly being involved in a conflictive way during adulthood can lead to states of anguish and absolute depression; mainly because human beings are eminently social and bonding, therefore, we need the bond to express ourselves as people. “No one is someone in the absence of others.”
In part, it would be true. A research project titled Toddlers Up and initiated by the University of Cambridge in 2010 aimed to identify the causes and influences behind children’s “social understanding” (their awareness of the thoughts and feelings of others) and explain why the of some children lags behind that of their peers. The prestigious university’s study is still ongoing and has led to the publication of 17 journal articles, several chapters and a book titled Social Understanding, Social Lives by project director Claire Hughes, which won the British Psychological Society Book Award in 2013.
In one of the conclusions of the analyzes carried out, the researchers state that, oftensiblings can have a positive effect on a child’s early development, even in cases where the relationship is not at all cordial and borders on conflictive.
To arrive at this statement, the professionals evaluated a total of 140 children from two to six years old who participated in the project. A wide range of tests were carried out over years of study, including video observations of children interacting with their parents, siblings, friends and strangers; interviews and questionnaires carried out with parents, teachers and the children themselves; and tests designed to assess children’s aptitude with language, planning skills, working memory, and inhibitory control.
Speaking to The Guardian, Claire Hughes said: “The traditional view is that have a brother or sister creates a lot of competition for parental attention and love. In fact, the balance of our evidence suggests that children’s social understanding may be accelerated by their interaction with siblings in many cases”.
Moche emphasizes that this is reflected in life itself: “no extreme is going to help us grow as people. The lack of debate prevents learning and if one becomes too competitive to the point of not finding any rewarding exchange, neither will one be taught or developed.”
Stella Maris De Vita, a graduate in Psychopedagogy, agrees that relationship between brothers It is unique and can have a significant influence on an individual. “Rivalry and competition is a normal part of development that can contribute to personal growth; siblings often act as important sources of emotional support,” she notes.
For the psychopedagogue, the arguments between brothers They offer opportunities for children to practice and develop solving skills. Thus, they learn to express opinions, listen to others and compare solutions that satisfy both parties, among many other benefits.
:format(jpeg)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/EPTPWNQOCVHZVHLKTOZXYJFNAM.jpg)
However, De Vita highlights that there are situations in which parents should be attentive to some signs that could indicate that conflict between siblings requires attention:
- Physical violence, such as hitting or kicking.
- Constant intimidation whether verbal or emotional. This can have lasting effects on self-esteem or emotional well-being.
- Pay attention to the significant and particular differences of each of the siblings that can color the way each subject acts (cognitive abilities, emotional maturity, chronological age, etc.).
- Constant exclusion, or marginalization, is indicative of relationship problems.
- Constant difficulties in resolving conflicts constructively.
The importance of this blood bond is such that Moche highlights: “siblings are the primary school for learning to build other significant bonds throughout life.”
When studying the observations of the children who participated in the project, the professionals noticed that when they were placed in an imaginary play environment, the children who were used to fighting with their siblings discussed their thoughts and feelings in depth, unlike those who were not. they did it.
On another occasion mentioned in the analysis, a younger brother who had shown a lower rate of mental development had improved socially by the age of six, as a result of having an older brother.
Moche adds that the exchange between minor children should always be regulated by the parents. He also explains that, on a general level, “When siblings continue to experience the same conflicts as they grow up, parents must question whether they have made mistakes, been unfair, or not paid enough attention to regulate those exchanges.”
Based on the above and if you notice that the conflict between siblings is too dizzying in childhood or remains the same when they are older, the Child Mind Institute of the United States suggests taking the following into account:
- Learn to manage conflicts between siblings in a healthy way to teach children skills such as turn-taking, sharing, body autonomy, when to turn to an adult, as well as using words instead of physical force to solve a problem.
- Identify patterns that lead to conflicts between children. Maybe deep down they fight because they want their parents’ attention.
- Let them know that, although you know they can resolve disagreements alone, they can always count on you for the most important problems.
- Teach them from childhood how to respond when a conflict begins; for example, “if he hits you, please don’t hit him back. Instead, tell us right away.”
Praise is also important for siblings. When parents see their children spending time together cooperatively or treating each other well, it’s helpful to point this out.
