Final arguments presented in new trial for “La Tombola Massacre”

Final arguments presented in new trial for “La Tombola Massacre”

The federal prosecutor’s office and the defense presented the closing arguments in the new trial against Alexis Candelario Santana for the call “Tombola Massacre” in 2009.

Despite the dozen years that have passed since the events in which eight people and an unborn baby were murderedthe Public Ministry did everything possible to keep the crudeness of the crime in mind before the jury.

In the closing arguments, the federal prosecutor Victor Acevedo summarized the allegations and the evidence while showing the jury some photos of the bodies of the victims of the brutal massacre at the “La Tombola” business in toa bajaas well as other people that Candelario Santana allegedly killed at the command of an organization of drug dealer which allegedly operated between 1993 and 2004.

“This case was about Alexis’s quest for power, money and control, which led to the murder of 21 people and the attempted murder of 19 people,” Acevedo said.

He recalled that Candelario Santana came to plead guilty in state courts for the murder of 12 people, but that from prison he began to send threats to the people who were left in charge of the gang because they stopped sending him “rent” payments for the sale of controlled substances.

The threats were against Wilfredo Semprit Santanaalias “Rufo”, star witness of the case and two other people.

“Alexis was furious,” the prosecutor said. “He wanted his (criminal) company back. He let Rufo and his wife know that when he got out (from prison) he was going to kill them.”

“After leaving in February 2009, he tried to follow through on his threat to go kill not only them, but everyone who was there,” he added.

He recounted what happened on December 16, 2009, when Semprit Santana opened the business “La Tombola”.

“There were children playing. It was a family event,” Acevedo said.

“But Alexis and others arrived with weapons and used them to shoot,” the prosecutor added, “resulting in the death of eight people and an unborn baby.” The photo of the creature was one of those projected to the jury.

Likewise, Acevedo highlighted that three people testified that they had heard Candelario Santana say: “No one comes out of here alive.”

He indicated that of those three people, Semprit Santana and Wilfredo Cancel Candelario declared that they had seen the defendant when he made that expression.

For his part, the lawyer Francisco Rebollo, legal representative of Candelario Santana, tried to convince the jurors that the defendant was not present at the scene.

He spent hours trying to make the jury doubt the testimonies given in the courtroom.

The defense did not present its own evidence, but used almost all of its time to argue that the statements of 19 people taken by the federal prosecutor’s office They do not corroborate the version of the star witness.

After indicating that Semprit Santana had reasons to present a version favorable to the prosecution, since he was accused of drug trafficking and had a collaboration agreement, Rebollo emphasized that the other witnesses are more credible since they do not have any incentive to point to the accused.

The lawyer argued that at least ten people who claimed to have been inside the business declared that they had seen only one person, identified as David Oquendostanding at the door of the premises that led to the area where there were some musical instruments and that she fired from what she called the “door of the fried foods”, as the star witness said.

The lawyer mentioned, for example, that Jose David Carmona Santos He declared that he took cover behind a column only to avoid Oquendo’s shots at the music door.

By showing a photo of the column, Rebollo indicated that if Rufo’s version was true, Carmona Santos “would have been exposed to the handle of the fried food door.”

“He doesn’t say he saw Alexis,” Rebollo maintained.

It also noted that Jose Amezquita, Aladino Amezquita and Oscar Gomez declared that they had been in the billiards area, where the wall that Rufo claimed to have used as a cover to fire back at the alleged attack by Candelario Santana is located.

According to Rebollo, none of these witnesses “says that Rufo was there shooting.”

Likewise, the lawyer insisted that the other witnesses did not say they had seen someone with long braids, as Semprit Santana described to the accused for that night.

Rebollo also recalled that Semprit Santana claimed to have fired 15 shots with a .40 caliber pistol, but stated that forensic evidence points to the discovery of three casings in the area of ​​the bar, alluding to the fact that another person was the one who answered the shooting attack. .

“The evidence does not support what Rufo says he did,” Rebollo said.

The prosecution will have the opportunity tomorrow, Wednesday, to answer Rebollo’s arguments in the rebuttal turn, before the jury retires to deliberate.

In the first trial, in March 2013, Candelario Santana was found guilty and was sentenced to life imprisonment by the then federal judge Jose A. Fusteafter a jury failed to reach a verdict for the death penalty.

After the sentence, in September 2013, he appealed the case and three years later it prospered when the Boston Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the ruling, accepting the defense’s request that an action by Fuste violated his constitutional right to a public trial.

Fuste pretended that he had ended a day of hearings and, later, when there was no public or press in the courtroom, he called the parties so that a witness who had informed the court that he feared being identified for fear of being a victim could testify in private. of retaliation.

“We cannot determine that the closure (of the court to the public) in this case is constitutionally permissible, and (the ruling) is revoked,” ordered the deceased. federal judge Juan R. Torruellaby ordering a new trial, which does not expose the defendant to the death penalty.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!