How is cyber security sovereignty in Ethiopia?

How is cyber security sovereignty in Ethiopia?

At the global level, the increasing prevalence of cyber security threats has led to alarming situations where cyber attacks are escalating. The high frequency of reported cyber attacks often targets critical infrastructures, raising serious concerns.

As indicated in the information, attacks on critical infrastructure can lead to numerous challenges. For instance, in 2021, the colonial pipeline in the United States experienced a significant cyber attack that resulted in a serious fuel supply disruption, showcasing how cyber attacks can jeopardize essential services.

These incidents highlight the need for improved protective measures within critical infrastructure. The ongoing rise in cyber threats necessitates a robust response strategy to safeguard vital services and ensure the security of these essential sectors.

In Ethiopia, the threat of cyber attacks is increasing. In the past year, there were 8,854 attempted cyber attacks, with the highest proportion targeting critical infrastructures. This indicates that most cyber attacks are focused on critical infrastructure.

These incidents highlight the necessity for the country to establish a robust framework for preventing cyber attacks, which includes addressing the technology needed for the protection of critical infrastructures.

October is designated as ‘Cyber Security Month,’ and it draws attention to the importance of securing critical infrastructures for digital sovereignty. This is crucial to ensure that Ethiopia’s key infrastructures undergo adequate research on cyber security vulnerabilities.

Research has indicated that between 2022 and 2023, there were numerous recorded attacks on critical infrastructures in the country, along with detailed accounts of incidents, measures taken, and solutions proposed.

According to Mr. Daniel Guta, the Director of Information Security Management, critical infrastructures may differ significantly depending on progress and interest from country to country. He emphasizes that vulnerable infrastructures in all countries are generally at risk. Countries should prioritize addressing their financial, technological, and human resource capacities, as well as recognizing their security challenges to cater to various critical infrastructures.

Based on this, 97 countries, including the United States and Malawi, have distinct critical infrastructures. The main sectors referred to as ‘critical infrastructures’ include health, information and communication technology, energy, security and safety, water and sanitation, industry, food, transportation, finance, and government services.

Mr. Daniel, who has made numerous efforts on behalf of many countries, asserts that these distinct infrastructures should be maintained and that there is a need for robust global systems to ensure cyber security. He emphasizes that in Ethiopia, with the ongoing significant cyber risks, it’s crucial to establish concrete measures for safeguarding cyber security.

The research identified four fundamental criteria for distinguishing critical infrastructures, according to Mr. Daniel. He mentions that critical infrastructures play an indispensable role in the country’s economic, social, and political development. The infrastructures, which support multiple sectors, are pivotal for national growth and often require high investment and protection. He notes that any damage to these infrastructures can have severe repercussions for national interests and security, as well as significantly impact citizens’ lives.

Mr Daniel Guta/ Photo INSA

Mr. Daniel suggests that unique safeguards are necessary for critical information infrastructures, as they are vital for the stability and well-being of the country and society. He states that without such measures in place, critical infrastructures can become vulnerabilities that pose threats from both domestic and foreign forces, thus amplifying the risks posed to national security and safety.

He also highlights that attacks on critical infrastructures can lead to significant disruptions in national benefits and security, necessitating urgent and robust responses to mitigate cyber threats. This is particularly relevant as these sectors often face various challenges, making it crucial to prioritize their protection to ensure their resilience against evolving threats.

As Mr. Daniel stated, the primary reason that necessitates research is the ongoing increase in cyber security threats to key infrastructures in the country. The responsibility for protecting key infrastructures lies predominantly with internal entities, however, to promptly address evolving digital transformation initiatives, a robust security framework is needed to establish national readiness. Additionally, developing systems that can effectively respond to cyber security incidents and mitigate their impacts is necessary to avoid the failure of national structures, as well as facilitate capacity assessment and evaluation.

As mentioned, attempts at cyber security attacks are increasing due to the growing connectivity and expansion of technology. When attacks occur on key infrastructures and services, they have adverse effects not only on the social and economic development of the country but also on peace and stability. The attackers may include corrupt countries, extortion groups, hackers, and criminal organizations.

In addition to protecting key infrastructures, Mr. Daniel emphasizes that there are specific measures implemented by the country concerning policy and law. He notes that the research has allowed for differentiation among entities that are overt threats, as well as highlighting the necessity for action in the event of such threats.

Among the threats, there are no clear criteria for distinguishing key infrastructures based on national-level regulations, however, the absence of national cyber security leadership remains a significant obstacle, as does the low priority given by the government to protecting these infrastructures, leading to a lack of clarity on their significance and the need for protection.

Aside from policies and standards, it is also noted that there are specific sectors where these infrastructures exist. Key infrastructure institutions are expected to develop and implement their own cyber security policies and standards. Although these entities may have policies in place, it has been noted that there are still gaps in their proactive and operational processes.

Within the internal sectors (such as finance – specifically regarding the national bank), while there may be ongoing efforts to establish their own cyber security systems, there are still significant gaps in many sectors regarding their operational capabilities.

For key information infrastructures, there is a lack of a robust reporting system to document cyber threats, attacks, or incidents. This absence means that entities do not have a response mechanism for national computer-related hazards, which is crucial for effective data exchange with the Ethiopian Computer Security Incident Response Team (Ethiopian CERT) and requires a well-established legal framework. Additionally, although there are databases and corrections provided by Ethiopia CERT, gaps remain in the implementation of necessary protocols.

As Mr. Daniel states, these gaps are interrelated with foundational arrangements. There are no sectoral CERTs to manage key infrastructures at a central level. Moreover, collaboration with entities that have been granted access to sharing data, knowledge, and experiences about cyber security is minimal.

Considering that even the foundational arrangements related to cyber security are lacking, the ability to exchange information, experiences, and knowledge with relevant entities is significantly hindered.

Mr. Daniel emphasizes that, in addition to creating departments focused on cyber security, there are also sectors that have been established for this purpose. He notes that, beyond managing Security Operations Centers (SOCs), there are numerous key infrastructure institutions where weaknesses are evident. Moreover, the establishment of Sectoral Computer Emergency Response Teams (Sectoral CERTs) is also noted as a significant concern, this would enhance the management of national information network security as well as sectoral incident response.

The research indicates that there are gaps in crucial legal frameworks, as Mr. Daniel points out. The corrective actions supplied by the national computer emergency response center are often inadequate to address these gaps. He highlights that while there are recognized standards and systems related to key infrastructures and their connection to cyber security, there are also shortcomings in their practical implementation.

As stated, the absence of thorough cyber security testing and assessment makes it difficult for these efforts to be based on global best practices. There is a lack of competence in applying the corrective measures provided during assessments. These reasons suggest that the management must be grounded in the accountability established by law, which involves monitoring and support, as well as effectively handling data exchange and other regulatory activities, while remaining susceptible to potential breaches.

The inability to hold accountable those entities responsible for enabling incidents has also been highlighted.

In managing cyber security, besides the establishment of dedicated departments, it is also noted that various actions have been taken and specific measures have been instituted to safeguard against cyber threats. It is said that there is an ongoing effort to develop a national cyber security policy to support these measures. According to the policy, key infrastructural developments should be prioritized, and there is a call for comprehensive discussions to draft laws that regulate critical infrastructure security, establish national frameworks, and ensure that the Ministry of Justice addresses the regulations necessary for a secure technology supply chain.

At the regulatory level, it is necessary to take actions that align with national laws to guide and shape the unique characteristics of the sector. There is also a need to refine policies, strategies, and essential frameworks that are deemed appropriate. Additionally, it’s emphasized that a reporting mechanism for cyber security incidents is crucial for receiving responses to security challenges in the sector.