In the hands of the Court of Appeals the future of the coalition candidacies between the MVC and the PIP

In the hands of the Court of Appeals the future of the coalition candidacies between the MVC and the PIP

A panel of judges of the Court of Appeals, in an oral hearing that attended today the claim of the Citizen Victory Movement (MVC) and the Puerto Rican Independence Party (PIPS) against the ban on joint candidacies, he inquired in depth about his power to intervene based on the “maturity” of the controversy and the element of the “political question” in which the Court of First Instance when it dismissed the lawsuit in June.

As part of the procedure before the intermediate forum, the two communities insisted that the legal impossibility of formalizing an alliance constitutes an unconstitutional violation of the freedom of association, as well as an unjustified impediment to the voters’ right to vote.

In contrast, the Attorney General Fernando Figueroa and the legal representation of the New Progressive Party (PNP) pointed, respectively, to the “speculative” nature of the intention of the MVC and the PIP to join forces, and to the “unfair” advantage that would imply for candidates to appear more than once on the ballot.

The presiding judge of the panel, Abelardo Bermudez Torres, seemed to distance himself from the approach regarding the absence of a real controversyciting a case decided on June 30 by the Supreme Court of the United States that, according to what he explained in court, substantially liberalized the standards of jurisdiction over the courts.

“The fact that there are two parties with (approved) resolutions, names seems more substantial to me… It is not a concern that something will be prohibited, but a legal reality that State Election Commission (CEE), when registering your candidates, tell them no,” said the magistrate, while alluding to the 303 Creative case, which revolved around the concern of a company that successfully challenged certain government requirements that would have been prospectively applied to it. if it chose to expand the scope of its business.

The attorney general, on behalf of the EEC, supported his assessment that the only thing in dispute is the “justiciability” of the case, in line with the determination of superior judge Raul Candelario Lopez, who concluded that the matter revolved around the “political question”.

Besides, both Figueroa and Francisco Gonzalez Magaz – a lawyer for the PNP electoral commissioner, Vanessa Santo Domingo – pointed out that the controversy is “premature”, since neither the PIP nor the MVC have defined their candidacies. The period for presenting candidacies extends from December 1 to 30 of the pre-election year.

However, Jorge Farinacci Fernos, representing the MVC, pointed out that as early as November the communities must notify the EEC of the mechanism they will use to select their candidates for the 2024 elections. Likewise, in response to a question from Bermudez Torres, rejected that resolving the lawsuit results in a mere consultative exercise in the event that the affiliates of both parties, ultimately, do not endorse the combined candidacies. “It would not be advisory because the ruling would have allowed (the applicants) to participate in the process. It’s not about the outcome,” the lawyer said.

Present at the hearing were, in the front row, the general secretary of the PIP, Juan Dalmau, who in the lawsuit maintains his intention to run for governor under the insignia of both parties, as well as Manuel Natal, general coordinator of the MVC, interested in a candidacy for mayor of San Juan.

Judge: “strict scrutiny” unnecessary

Bermudez Torres, who made most of the interventions during the nearly three-hour hearing, alluded to multiple cases at the federal level and in various states of the United States in which the courts have ruled that, in order to restrict a fundamental right -such as of association–, a “strict scrutiny” of the need for it is not required, but an exercise of “balancing of interests” in which the State justifies the limitations.

In particular, the jurist pointed out, the courts have resorted to the most limited standard when the restriction of the fundamental right “is not serious or onerous.” Likewise, he alluded to jurisprudence that has concluded that coalitions tend to “confuse” voters or result in acts of corruption.

Constitutionalist Carlos Gorrin Peralta, on behalf of the PIP, countered that, even under a more flexible standard, the ban on coalition candidacies would not be upheld because the “interest” arises from the electoral law or the arguments of the case. of the government in restricting freedom of association. During the hearing, PNP lawyer Ramon Rosario Cortes compared the possibility of an applicant appearing in more than one space on the ballot with the unfair advantage that having a larger photo would produce for a candidate.

Gorrin Peralta’s argument seemed to find an echo in judge Giselle Romero Garcia, who stressed that neither in the preamble to the electoral laws of 2011 and 2020, nor in the legislative debates, was the need to prohibit formal alliances substantiated. Coalitions were allowed until the signing of Law 78 of 2011.

The third judge on the panel, Jose Monge Gomez, inquired whether the prohibition of alliances affects additional rights to freedom of association, as well as the internal procedures of the parties to direct the alliances, to which Gorrin Peralta replied that the restriction prevents the full exercise of the right to vote and that, in the case of the PIP, “the process has already begun.”

On behalf of the Popular Democratic Party (PPD), Mr. Gerardo de Jesus Annoni opined that the Appeals Court should enter into the merits of the controversy but that, in his opinion, the prohibition of the alliances only implies a “minimum limitation”. voters’ rights and that the government has an interest in “simplifying” the electoral system.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!