:format(jpeg):focal(381x173:391x163)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/35JKM3CBCNFR7DWJTPZVSZIWTM.jpg)
There are many debates that revolve around whether or not it is advisable to train on an empty stomach. There are theories that exercising on an empty stomach promotes weight loss; At the other extreme are those who say that eating food before training is necessary. to have energy and muscles to function correctly. What is the indicated theory? Is fasting applied equally to all people and sports?
The relationship you have with your diet before physical exercise will impact performance and general health. Specifically, when it comes to intermittent fasting – a practice that is based on abstaining from consuming food for a minimum of 12 hours -, sports doctor Alejandra Hintze talks about the importance of understanding that it has to do with a nutritional technique that It is worth implementing it on certain occasions and on certain people.
“Not everyone will benefit from intermittent fasting,” says the expert. For example, “a gluten-free diet is not recommended for everyone. Those who have to eat this way are those with celiac disease and those intolerant to gluten,” explains Hintze and clarifies that this same reasoning applies to intermittent fasting. “There will always be those who benefit and those who don’t,” she adds.
Joaquin Gonzalez Saucedo, a nutritionist specialized in high-performance sports, comments that pTo achieve the desired objectives, you must plan with the help of a health professional, and in an individualized manner., the type of diet and exercise that will be carried out taking into account the physical conditions, lifestyle and needs of each person. “It should be noted, for example, that the same rules do not work for an elite athlete as for an amateur, regardless of the fact that there are certain guidelines in common for everyone,” he mentions.
“Intermittent fasting before training has advantages, but not for all athletes,” says Hintze. In long-term endurance sports such as triathlon, swimming, a marathon or trail running in the mountains, “it is totally inadvisable not to eat because the body needs to have glucose reserves to move for many hours,” the doctor details.
Otherwise, “the body will attack its own sources of glucose and a weakening condition could occur,” the sports specialist explains. For Hintze, this situation prevents good sports performance due to lack of energy.
Even so, there are many who decide to do aerobic exercise on an empty stomach with the excuse that it helps them lose weight. “The discussion starts here,” says Hintze. “There is no doubt that you can run 13 miles fasting, but the performance is not going to be the best,” clarifies. You cannot expect to achieve a workout giving one hundred percent on an empty stomach “because you are in a caloric deficit; and although the body can resist it, the final result will not be as expected unlike if it had been eaten for breakfast,” she specifies.
A report from the Runner’s World portal cites a study carried out by the University of Nottingham in the United Kingdom that mentions that taking a walk after seven hours of fasting could be an effective strategy to increase fat oxidation. However, they assure that there is a risk of losing performance. Another research published by the International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism, highlights that performing moderate aerobic exercise to lose adipose tissue after fasting does not always improve the use of lipids, therefore they specify that it is advisable to do resistance exercise after a light food intake.
When it comes to strength training, Gonzalez Saucedo suggests avoiding the practice of intermittent fasting, especially if the goal is to gain muscle mass. This is because food is considered the fuel for the muscles: “It provides them with the energy they need to carry weight and then repair their fibers and tissues,” highlights the nutritionist.
In these cases, it suggests having breakfast at least an hour before training and opting for foods that “provide energy, which is essential to store in the muscles and that will allow the person to carry out the activity as efficiently as possible.”
Among them, those that contain healthy fats such as avocado or nuts, and complex carbohydrates such as legumes and cereals stand out. Proteins complete the list because they act on muscle tissues. The suggested ones are eggs, deep-sea fish such as salmon, tuna, trout and lean meats since they have little fat and also provide calcium, vitamin D, B12, fiber and omega 3, essential nutrients for the proper functioning of the skeletal muscle system.
After a workout of this caliber, Gonzalez Saucedo talks about the need to recover damaged muscle mass and fibers and promote the synthesis of new tissue. For this, the best option, says the nutritionist, are protein foods and simple carbohydrates: fruits and milk since they are quickly digested and will return the energy it lost to the body. For the specialist, it is indicated to consume them two hours after training, a time when the body is still burning calories.
In this regard, recent research called into question the idea of fasting before doing strength training by demonstrating that people who exercised after eating a meal had a greater gain in muscle mass, and it was even observed that they were able to load more weight in exercises such as squats unlike those who trained in the same way but on an empty stomach.
The analysis compared two groups of participants who were fasting for Ramadan, a date on which Muslims fast for 30 days to commemorate Muhammad’s first revolution. One of them was asked to train without breaking their fast – which is usually at sunset -; the other had instructions to do it after having eaten. It should be noted that all participants, regardless of the group to which they have been assigned, When they could eat, they did it the same way. The group that exercised on an empty stomach reported a higher level of demand and effort when executing the movements compared to the participants who ate.
On the other hand, “in sports that do not use glucose, for example, martial arts, which are usually short in duration and do not involve running, fasting carries almost no risk nor does it have any drawbacks. It’s okay if you don’t have glucose in your body because it’s not used in these types of activities,” says Hintze.
The specialists consulted agree that, although there are people who will benefit from fasting, for example, those who need to reduce the level of bad cholesterol (LDL) in the blood or those who have to lose weight, the truth is that training on an empty stomach may not be entirely advantageous to others. “In addition to reducing sports performance, it can cause headaches, constipation, a feeling of fatigue and body weakness,” Hintze lists and comments that there are people who, no matter how much they want to, cannot tolerate spending “12, 14 or 16 hours without eating and continuing with their daily lives.”
For her part, Analia Yamaguchi, a clinical doctor specializing in nutrition, warns that a common mistake is to do intermittent fasting throughout the day and train in the afternoon. “Those who do this frequently could fall into malnutrition.” From Hintze’s point of view, it is important that in the hours when you are not fasting, you have a healthy and balanced diet. “It makes no sense not to eat for so many hours and then exceed your calorie intake. Fasting fails when food intake is overcompensated.
