A prosecutor stated that the teenager who killed two students and two teachers at school Appalachian Highin Georgiacarefully planned the murder with the specific goal of becoming famous, while a defense attorney argued that those terrible acts were those of a vulnerable and neglected child.
Colt Gray, 16, pleaded guilty last week to 55 charges, including murder, in connection with the Sept. 4, 2024, shooting.in which several other people were also injured at the school, located about 45 miles northeast of Atlanta.
The minimum penalty for murder in Georgia is life in prison with the possibility of parole. This leaves Barrow County Superior Court Judge Nicholas Primm with the dilemma of deciding whether Gray will ever be eligible for parole.
District Attorney Brad Smith told the judge that Gray “cannot be free.”
“We have seen no indication that he has any capacity to develop a conscience or to fully value human life,” Smith said.
Defense attorney W. Charlton Allen told the judge that his client “is not hopelessly lost.” Granting him the possibility of parole would give him “a chance at hope,” Allen said, adding that without hope, “you are deprived of the ability to change.”
Teachers Richard “Ricky” Aspinwall, 39, and Cristina Irimie, 53, as well as students Mason Schermerhorn and Christian Angulo, both 14, died in the shooting. Another teacher and eight other students were injured, seven of them by gunshots.
Victims of the shooting and relatives of the dead expressed their anger and pain to Primm on Friday, with nearly all of them asking him to impose a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Shayna Aspinwall, wife of math teacher and soccer coach Richard Aspinwall, described “a life sentence of pain and trauma for those left behind.”
He aspired to become the perpetrator of a mass shooting
Investigators testified during the sentencing hearing that Gray idolized other perpetrators of mass shootings and talked about them online with other members of the “true crime community,” a group of young people who gather online and are fascinated by these types of attacks.
Gray had discussed online his intention to achieve notoriety through a school shooting and had expressed his admiration for other perpetrators of mass shootings. Some aspects of his preparation and behavior, both before and after the Apalachee High School shooting, mimicked those of other mass shooters, one investigator said.
Prosecutors played recordings of phone conversations Gray had with his mother, Marcee Gray, from a juvenile detention center in the months after the shooting. During those calls, he asked his mother to look up what people were saying about him on the Internet. When she described “fan art” drawings featuring him or comments people made about him, he asked her how much interaction those posts generated and seemed to get excited when they got a lot.
“The shooting was not the culmination of the plan. The shooting was just one step in the plan. The plan was to achieve ultimate and lasting fame within TCC,” Smith said, referring to the “true crime community.”

Teenager’s grandmother says he needed help
Gray’s maternal grandmother, Debbie Polhamus, testified that the teenager had had a difficult childhood and that his parents had failed him. According to her, her grandson had become “very restless and aggressive” in the weeks before the shooting, adding that he had urged his parents to get him help, but that they had done nothing about it.
“I tried to help Colt because no one else was doing it,” she said.
Polhamus said he visits his grandson once a week in a juvenile detention center and that he has improved greatly thanks to treatment and medication.
“He’s much better. Colt badly needed a routine,” she said.
She said her grandson has been reading a lot and wants to go to school and study to get his GED. He urged the judge to grant him the opportunity for parole.
“I would like him, at some point, to have the opportunity to prove himself,” Polhamus said.

Candice Broce, director of the State Division of Family and Children Services and commissioner of the Georgia Department of Social Serviceswas called to testify by Colt Gray’s lawyer. She took charge of Gray’s case after he was placed in a foster family while in detention, since he was a minor and his father was in prison. There were also concerns regarding his mother’s contact with him.
Broce stated that Gray seemed to show improvement during treatment. After Marcee Gray was prohibited from speaking to her son under a July 2025 restraining order and he began taking medication, staff at the juvenile detention center later told Broce that it had “turned him, in essence, into a different child,” she said..
