President Donald Trump’s lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) for the leak of her tax returns was filed for an “improper purpose,” a judge said Monday in a forceful decision that referred to one of her lawyers for possible disciplinary action and called the $10 billion lawsuit a self-serving exercise.
U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams accused Trump and his lawyers of manipulating the judicial system by suing a federal agency under his own control, skirting the requirement that parties to litigation must have competing interests and laying the groundwork for a deal that gave him immunity from tax audits and created a fund to compensate allies of the president who say they were unfairly persecuted.
The judge stopped short of expressly nullifying the agreement that protected Trump from tax scrutiny, but held that the government cannot claim that the agreement was the result of a legitimate legal process.
1 / 20 | With claims of revenge against Donald Trump: Iran’s supreme leader, Ali Khamenei, is fired. Iran began a procession through its capital Tehran on Monday for the funeral of the late Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. -Altaf Qadri
“The question of whether executive branch officials can privately agree to grant themselves and their former clients blanket immunity and billions of taxpayer dollars to redress grievances not defined by law has never arisen before this court.”said Williams, an appointee of President Barack Obama. “The question is whether the parties could do so by claiming to be adversaries and resorting to the legitimacy of a judicial process. The answer is a resounding ‘no’.”
The ruling comes just before a key confirmation hearing
Although the practical consequences of the ruling may be limited, since the lawsuit was dropped months ago and the administration had already abandoned the $1.776 billion “Anti-Weaponization Fund” that arose from that agreement, the order constitutes a sharp rebuke and opens a politically uncomfortable line of questioning for acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, who will appear before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Wednesday for his confirmation hearing.
“The very nature of the lawsuit and the conduct of the parties and their attorneys since its filing make it clear that this was an attempt to use the court to confer some legitimacy on an agreement intended to grant immunity to individuals and entities linked to the president, as well as to set aside billions of American taxpayer dollars to redress grievances that are not covered by law,” Williams wrote in his ruling.
And he added: “The president may be, in practice, the ‘dominus litis’ of the Executive Branch, but as a party in a civil proceeding, he and all parties and attorneys who appear before a court are subject to the rules. “Ensuring that our courts are used only for the purposes expressly provided for by the Constitution is an obligation of all judges and an obligation that this court must fulfill in light of the matter before it.”
The lawsuit filed in January against the IRS and the Treasury Department accused both federal agencies of failing to prevent the leak of the president’s tax information to various media between 2018 and 2020.
However, in May the administration announced that it had reached an agreement to resolve the case and create a fund to compensate people who believe they have been treated unfairly by the criminal justice system. That fund was quickly shelved after receiving bipartisan criticism, although the Trump administration has said it intends to move forward with another component of the deal that would give Trump and members of his family protection from tax audits.
From the beginning, the judge was skeptical of the lawsuit and appointed a group of lawyers to determine whether a conflict of interest existed, given that, as sitting president, Trump was suing “entities whose decisions are subject to his direction.”
Even after the settlement was known, he ordered Trump’s lawyers to lay out their positions on whether the parties in the case were truly adversaries, whether the agreement was based on fraud and whether the case should be reopened.
In her ruling she made it clear that the lawyers’ responses did not convince her.
“After reviewing the record and the parties’ statements, the court refuses to accept the naive exercise of disassociating President Trump’s current position from an understanding of what occurred in this case,” he wrote.
Ruling also raises possibility of disciplinary sanctions
The judge referred Trump attorney Alejandro Brito, who filed the lawsuit, for possible disciplinary action before the Florida Bar and noted that another attorney, Daniel Epstein, will not be granted permission to file briefs with the Southern District of Florida for a period of up to one year.
A spokesperson for Trump’s legal team responded to a request for comment on Brito’s behalf with a statement blaming the IRS for allowing the president’s tax returns to be leaked.
The judge also ordered that her ruling be forwarded to the bars of New York State and the District of Columbia, where ethics complaints have been filed against Blanche and Deputy Attorney General Stanley Woodward.
Williams pointed to testimony Blanche gave before Congress in early June, in which she revealed that the “Anti-Weaponization Fund” would no longer move forward. Although no document had been filed with the court, Blanche was confident in stating that “he could speak on behalf of both parties and legally bind them,” Williams said.
“Acting Attorney General Blanche’s apparent ability to speak for both plaintiffs and defendants, sign a ‘settlement’ document on behalf of all parties to this action, and then repudiate part of that settlement demonstrates that throughout this entire case there was only one party whose interests were represented,” the judge wrote.
The judge also raised ethical concerns about Blanche and Woodward’s involvement in negotiating the deal, given Blanche’s history as Trump’s lawyer, as well as Woodward’s previous defense of defendants in the Jan. 6 Capitol assault and a Trump co-defendant in the classified documents case.
“Rather than recusing themselves due to their prior representations or vigorously defending this lawsuit, as required by Department of Justice policies and procedures, these attorneys agreed to a ‘settlement’ involving an extraordinary amount of money and potentially benefiting former clients,” he said.
Blanche denied in an interview with CNN last spring that he had worked out the terms of the deal, saying: “The president has outside lawyers, and it is they, along with the Department of Justice, who represent him, not me.”
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
