The federal government cannot prevent benefits from the country’s largest food aid program from being used to buy candy, soda and other sugary drinks, a judge has ruled.
The ruling stops the restrictions that are already in force or planned in 23 states for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP, in English)financed by the federal government and managed by the states. President Donald Trump’s administration has not indicated whether it will appeal to a higher court.
U.S. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson, based in Washington and appointed to the position by the former president Barack Obamanoted in its ruling that the sentence was due to the federal government’s failure to comply with its own definition of “food.” He clarified that this was not a statement about whether the restrictions are a good idea.
“Federal defendants and states may have a genuine desire to improve the health of SNAP recipient households by encouraging healthy choices at the store, and they may take legal steps to achieve those goals,” he wrote. “But what they can’t do is break the law and their own rules at the same time.”
The restrictions are part of the Health Secretary’s campaign
Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.have encouraged states to limit the products that can be purchased with food aid, as part of the “Make America Healthy Again” campaign.
They argue that soft drinks and candy contribute to the rise in obesity, diabetes and chronic diseases, and that their exclusion from the list would encourage healthier food choices.
1 / 10 | They impact hundreds of mothers who are heads of families in Barrio Obrero with food. On the basketball court of the Barrio Obrero Head Start center, in Santurce, dozens of mothers of minors collected boxes with fresh food and other items for their children this Friday. – Carlos Rivera Giusti
Until now, the Federal Department of Agriculture (USDA, in English) has authorized 23 states to impose restrictions. Some have already been implemented, while others are scheduled to come into force in the coming months and years.
At least one state that planned to limit the purchase of soda and candy changed course earlier this year. The Colorado Board of Human Services voted against enforcing the ban following a hearing in March, in which SNAP recipients and advocates said people would face stigma if they mistakenly tried to use benefits on prohibited items. They also noted that the rules were confusing, as they would have allowed the purchase of drinks with at least 50% fruit or vegetable juice, but not those with less.
Although the goals are similar, the specific rules vary by state. Some wanted to ban sugary drinks and candy, while others only wanted to ban the former.
SNAP recipients in Colorado, Iowa, Nebraska, Tennessee and West Virginia have filed a court challenge against the ban on candy and soda, which in some states includes products such as sports drinks.
He claims that the definition of food was ignored
Jackson noted that the main legal error in restricting what could be purchased with SNAP benefits was because it contradicted the definition of “food” established by Congress.
Under the law, SNAP benefits — formerly known as food stamps — can be used for “any food or food product intended for home consumption, except alcoholic beverages, tobacco, hot foods, or hot food products ready for immediate consumption.”
The government may waive certain requirements, but limiting the use of benefits intended to improve nutrition is not listed as a reason for doing so. However, when states asked the USDA to allow them to restrict purchases, their requests included the use of alternative definitions of the term “food.”

This may not be the last thing said
Rollins suggested on social media that the government “will continue to fight to make America a healthy country again,” although he did not directly clarify whether an appeal would be filed. Rollins stated that “an activist judge just blocked our common sense restriction on the use of SNAP benefits for soda and junk food.”
The case is one of dozens of challenges to the Trump administration’s policies that depend on whether the government has the authority to modify those policies without congressional approval.
Although it is a great program that helps nearly 39 million Americans—about 1 in 9—buy food, SNAP often goes largely unnoticed. But the situation has changed since Trump returned to office last year.
Under the sweeping tax and policy law passed last year, more recipients are subject to work requirements and states are required to bear a greater share of administrative costs; In addition, they may have to bear the costs of services if their error rates are too high.
Last year, during a government shutdown, the courts prevented the administration from suspending benefits. For his part, Rollins has claimed that there is widespread fraud in the program.
