Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – The decision on the criminal responsibility of Elvia Cabrera Rivera will remain from tomorrow, Thursday, in the hands of the 12 members of the jury, who will retire to deliberate on the accusation for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old.
The decisive stage will come after the Prosecutor’s Office and the defense present their final arguments and the judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri, of the Aibonito Courtgave part of the instructions to the jury, made up of seven women and five men.
According to the established schedule, the judge will finish reading the instructions to the jury in the morning. Then, he or she will appoint a president. Subsequently, the deliberation process will begin to reach a verdict in the case.
One aspect that particularly caught our attention is that, although the defendant faces charges of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law, The jury may also consider a mitigated murder verdict if it concludes that the events occurred under the element of sudden pendency.
While the robed officer gave the instructions, the accused sometimes looked toward the stand, toward the computers on the defense table, and toward the jury. The latter, on the other hand, remained attentive to the document that the judge was reading.
1/12 | This is what the Aibonito Court looks like during the final stage of the trial against Elvia Cabrera. The trial against Elvia Cabrera Rivera, accused of the murder of the minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16, entered its 22nd day this Wednesday, with the final arguments before the jury that will have the responsibility of issuing a verdict. – Pablo Martinez
“It is up to you (jury) to decide on the credibility of each witness,” said Barreto Altieri, who went, point by point, explaining crucial details about the evidence so that the panel of citizens can retire to deliberate and issue a verdict.
The events date back to the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, during the celebration of the Great Municipal Summer Closing in Aibonito, when a brawl escalated into a knife attack in which two teenagers were injured.
One of the victims was Pratts Rosario, affectionately known by her family as “Lela,” who was rushed to the Menonita Hospital, where Dr. Carla Mercado certified his death at 12:35 am on Monday, August 11, 2025.
Likewise, Chrisangel Gonzalez RodriguezPratts Rosario’s best friend, was also stabbed during the incident. The young man survived a stab wound to the back of his back, near his spine, and later testified at trial.
Due to these facts, the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office On August 19, 2025, he filed two charges against the accused and her daughter. Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera, 18 years old, for the crimes of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law for the use and/or carrying of a knife.
According to the Prosecutor’s theory, both defendants acted in common and mutual agreement in the commission of the crime, which was allegedly perpetrated with a sharp object “about one inch wide and five inches long, with a sharp tip, or a similar object that could be considered a knife.”
However, during the trial it was not conclusively established what the murder weapon was, since three objects were discussed: a blade found near the defendant’s residence, a pink comb with a stainless steel blade hidden in the handle, and an awl.
1/9 | Images from Aibonito: the trial against Elvia Cabrera in its final stage. The trial against Elvia Cabrera Rivera, accused of the death of the young Gabriela Nicole Pratts, is in its culminating stage after 21 days of testimony. In the photo, a sign in front of one of the houses located around the Aibonito Court. – Pablo Martinez
The victim had 11 wounds caused by a knife, the pathologist declared Javier Gustavo Serrano when presenting the results of the autopsy. The expert indicated that Pratts Rosario had a wound that reached his heart and was what caused his death.
In the judicial process, the Prosecutor’s Office had 61 witnesses, of which 21 testified in court and the rest was stipulated by agreement between the parties. Meanwhile, the defense chose not to call any witnesses to testify. Both parties considered the case submitted on July 21.
Subsequently, the Prosecutor’s Office and the defense addressed the seven women and five men who made up the jury during their final arguments, in which they reviewed the evidence presented in the trial, whose parade of evidence began on May 1.
On the one hand, the Prosecutor’s Office asked the jurors to evaluate the entirety of the evidence and issue a guilty verdict against the accused.
“That day, August 10, Elvia Cabrera, instead of protecting her daughter, incited violence; instead of stopping the danger, she fueled it. Today you represent the voice of justice, each and every one of you. This verdict that you are going to issue cannot be based on compassion for the accused; it must be based on the evidence that you heard,” said prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto in the courtroom.
1/9 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
“Today Gabriela Nicole’s voice cannot be heard, but the voice of justice is in her hands. “I, for Gabriela, for the law, for justice and because I represent the people of Puerto Rico, respectfully request that you issue a guilty verdict on each of the charges,” he added in his turn, which lasted more than 50 minutes.
For its part, the defendant’s defense emphasized that the Prosecutor’s Office failed to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt and requested a not guilty verdict. Likewise, the innocence of Cabrera Rivera was insisted.
“Justice does not ask for courage to condemn, it asks for honesty to be able to recognize the true facts… Sometimes the most difficult verdict is not guilty, but the correct one,” he said. Alberto Rivera Ramos, lawyer for the accused.
In his turn to speak, the lawyer acknowledged the pain caused by Gabriela Nicole’s crime, but emphasized that the trial did not revolve around determining whether a tragedy occurred, but rather establishing whether the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office had presented sufficient evidence to demonstrate Cabrera Rivera’s responsibility.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
“This trial cannot return a daughter to her mother or repair that void, but what you can do as a jury is prevent another tragedy from occurring… The second tragedy is convicting someone innocent,” Rivera Ramos pointed out.
