Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – In heartbreaking testimony, the cousin of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old, murdered on Sunday, August 10, 2025, recounted the moment when “Lela”, as she was affectionately called, closed her eyes for the last time in the Roberto Colon detourin Aibonitewhile she begged him to get up.
On the twentieth day of the jury trial against Elvia Cabrera Riveraheld in Room 1 of the Aibonite Court before the judge Luis S. Barreto Altierithe youngest JNRS testified that he witnessed when Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera He allegedly stabbed the victim and then his mother picked up an object from the floor.
At the beginning of his statement, during the prosecutor’s interrogation Myriam Nieves Verathe 16-year-old witness, who on several occasions could not contain her tears and spoke with a tone of voice that at times was barely audible, described the relationship she had with her cousin as “very good” and “very special.”
Entering the night of the crime, he said that he went to the detour with a group of friends to attend the Great Municipal Summer Closing. Like other testimonies, JNRS explained that, at some point, they intended to eat at a nearby establishment, but when they found it closed they returned to the detour area.
That’s when he heard Lismary Torressister of the victim, speaking on the phone. He remembered that the conversation became heated and that Lismary shouted an offensive expression. Then, Faviola AvilesAnthonieska’s sister, picked up the phone and challenged the person who was on the call to come to the scene.
1/8 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
Shortly after, he declared, Gabriela Nicole called her aunt Lisandra Rosario Berrioswho later left El Maestro Liquor Store. “I watched her because I got out of the car,” narrated witness #20 of the Public Ministry, who continued her story explaining how, little by little, tempers began to heat up.
“Miriathny (Aviles Rodriguez, Anthonieska’s half-sister) arrives and starts fighting with Faviola. They were arguing and Miriathny kind of hit Faviola. They seem to have started hitting each other. Yeddiel starts saying: ‘Wow, wow, wow, you are sisters’. After that, Yeddiel says: ‘let’s give them a fight.’ break so that the two of them can talk alone,’” the young woman recalled.
In the middle of the situation, the accused arrived at the detour, accompanied by her daughters. Anthonieska and Anthiany Aviles Cabrera; Gabriela “Gaba” Figueroa ArroyoAnthonieska’s best friend; and other women whose names the witness said she did not know, although she stated under oath that they were all of legal age.
“They came to where we were. They were upset. You could see it in their faces and in their attitude. Antho said (something). Anthiany punched Lismary. Then, Lismary kind of fell because she’s smaller and Anthiany is bigger. (Then) Titi started to defend her because they jumped on her,” she said.
“Titi was hitting Gaba and they started hitting Titi too. I was with Lela (Gabriela Nicole) by the railings (of the detour). Lela starts to say: ‘Let her go, let her go’, and at that moment Antho jumps on her. He kind of approached her and grabbed her by the hair. He started hitting her and had her looking down. Then, I see Gaba coming. “I pulled Antho because of the fucking light she had in her head,” he added.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
Given some objections raised by the accused’s legal team, the judge decided to activate Rule 109 of Evidence, so the jury was removed from the room while the admissibility of that part of the testimony was discussed, as well as other much more forceful statements that JNRS would later make.
“After that, someone came and grabbed me by the hair and hit me by the head. Yandriel grabs me by the waist and makes me let go of Antho. I see that Antho and Lela were looking down, holding each other by the hair, walking towards where they were beating Titi and Lismary across the grass,” said the teenager.
“I don’t know how to say it. They had her looking down. Lela was trying to raise her head to get out. I lost sight of Lela. Yandriel was telling me to calm down. Then, I go to Yandriel’s car and I see Lela lying in the shape of a fetus on the floor trying to cover herself with her arms and Antho was kneeling, like in the area of her legs,” the witness asserted.
Then the testimony took a poignant turn. The young woman, who was 15 years old at the time of the events, recounted how her cousin closed her eyes while she and other people desperately begged her to get up, although the victim remained completely motionless on the ground.
“I see (Antho) that he was punching. He was making some movements from the outside towards Lela’s body. I saw Elvia, who was nearby, and Titi says: ‘Who is giving him my daughter? Who is giving him my daughter?’. And Elvia goes to where Titi is. And Antho stopped and backed into the middle of the road. I go to where Lela and Lela had the suit up to her waist. You couldn’t see his navel. And I started to say to her: ‘Lela, get up, Lela, get up, please,’ and at that moment she closed her eyes,” he commented.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
After the strong testimony, the robed man declared a recess. The witness looked unbalanced and asked for water. Coincidentally, after work in the room stopped for a moment, the electricity service went out for a moment, leaving it in darkness. At that moment, the clock read exactly 9:41 am.
Then, the statement resumed and the witness stated: “Lela had the suit up to her waist. You couldn’t see her navel. She had the panties light and were stained with blood. I noticed that Lela had two broken bones in her hip, between her hip and her buttock.”
“I stayed in shock and I start to touch Lela and I see that her suit is torn around the chest. I tried to put my leg in to try to lift it because I wanted it to get up, but it wouldn’t get up. And I see two (more) breaks in her chest and I put her back on the floor. Paola (Carpena, best friend of the victim’s sister) comes and disorients her and tells her: ‘Lela, get up, please.’ Then Dylan yelled, ‘Lela, f#$@.’ There everyone reacted and went to Lela,” he said.
JNRS recalled how several of his friends carried the victim, who “was very heavy in the legs.” “They put her in the car. Yandriel tells me to pick up the things: some of Paola’s brown flip-flops that were lying on the grass. There I saw that Elvia took her large Coach purse with one hand and with the other she picked up an object from the floor as if trying to hide it because I saw the movement. It was finite because of how he picked it up (the object). I was three feet away,” the minor mentioned when asked by the prosecutor.
“Elvia looked at me and told me: ‘You didn’t see anything’. I told her: ‘Go to hell’ because I was upset by everything that had happened,” added the witness, who then proceeded to review the sworn statement she gave to the authorities and added that the accused said this expression to her in a defiant and strong tone.
As part of the controversy over the admissibility of that expression that the witness alleges the accused said, the attorney Yancarlos Maysonet Hernandez he opposed their admission. He stated, among other things, that the statements were totally surprising for the defense, since it was not in the evidence delivered as part of the discovery.
For her part, the prosecutor objected to the defense’s arguments and asked that it be admitted. Given what was stated by the parties, the court declared a recess. Upon his return, the robed man explained the reasons why the court was going to allow this part of the testimony, which was later heard by the jury.
