The senator for Popular Democratic Party (PPD) Luis Javier Hernandez went before the Court of Appeals to insist that the Department of Justice give him copies of the closure orders of 229 investigations involving public servants and that were archived since September 2025, and thus revoke a decision of the Court of First Instance that did not recognize his authority to do so.
According to the legal appeal submitted by Hernandez’s legal team to the Court of Appealsthe lower-ranking forum erred in considering that the legislator lacked active standing in the case, since the Senate approved a motion, on May 21, that authorized him to demand the documents in court.
“If the body of the Senate, the plenary session, authorized through a motion to appear, then I do not believe that it would be an obstacle for that information to be given to us. It is a novel issue, it is the first time in history that a minority senator goes to court to request information”said Hernandez, in a telephone interview.
On June 2, Judge Anthony Cuevas dismissed the case against the Department of Justice, considering that Hernandez lacks “active standing” for acting in an individual capacity and not channeling the request through the president or vice president of the Senate, to whom the Political Code recognizes that power.
The PPD minority leader in the Senate seeks that, with the case, new jurisprudence is established that recognizes powers of all legislators and does not centralize them in the figures of the president or vice president of the Senate alone.
“What happens if the president of the Senate does not want to go and ask for information that a minority senator requires? Are we without a remedy?” he questioned.
To questions from this medium about what inhibits him from requesting the president of the Senate, Thomas Rivera Schatzor the vice president Carmelo Rios submitting the motion on his behalf, the popular senator insisted that both expressed their support through the plenary vote on the motion, which was unanimous.
In his legal appeal, Hernandez relies on the Constitution, previous cases and the Senate’s Rules of Procedure and Internal Government to justify his position before the Appeals Court panel.
According to the document, Neither the Constitution nor the Regulations “establish any distinction or classification regarding the position held by a member of the Senate” and their powers to supervise.
“On the contrary, it is extremely broad and liberal, allowing any senator to carry out his constitutional work of legislating, investigating, supervising, discussing and disclosing public matters,” indicates the appeal.
Furthermore, Hernandez relied on the fact that the Constitution does not give exclusive powers to the president or vice president of the Senate, so the lack of legitimation in his case is not justified.
“The reading that the Court of First Instance makes of Article 34-A (of the Political Code) is a restrictive reading that would generate constitutional doubts if we analyze it in conjunction with Article III of the Constitution of Puerto Rico,” Hernandez denounced in the document.
For the PPD spokesperson, the most important question in this process is why the Department of Justice refuses to deliver the requested documents.
“What is the Department of Justice hiding? Why do you refuse to give us that information? Why don’t you want a minority senator to be able to examine archived cases of government corruption? We are in a moment of great disbelief among people towards the government, and this, instead of giving people peace of mind, what arouses conjectures and concerns,” he stressed.
Among the closed investigations is the one that, since 2022, has weighed on the Secretary of the Family, Suzanne Roig Fuertesfor alleged irregular acts committed while working in a management position of the Department of Health the past quadrennium. In this case, Justice did share a copy of the file.
“I could file this under the Transparency Law, but you will remember that the Transparency Law was amended by this government to give the government more time to deliver documentation and make it more difficult for citizens and the media to access documentation,” Hernandez said.
He anticipated that, if he did not succeed in the appeal forum, he would take the case to the Supreme Court and “to the last consequences.”
“Let the Department of Justice know that, even if it refuses to give me the information, at some point, I will have access.”asserted Hernandez.
