Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
An alleged statement with which Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera would have exonerated his mother, Elvia Cabrera Riveraand his sister, Anthianyfor the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario sparked an intense debate at the trial.
The discussion arose Wednesday after Rule 109 of Evidence was activated, which allows the court to evaluate the admissibility of evidence without the presence of the jury. The approach was attended to by the Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri in room 1 of the Aibonite Court.
In summary, the defense tried to explore an alleged statement that Aviles Cabrera – daughter of Cabrera Rivera and also a co-accused – would have made to the agent Veronica Lugoafter being read the “Miranda warnings for a suspicious person in custody.”
The alleged statement in controversy was: “My mother and sister were not involved”. That alleged manifestation was revealed for the first time on December 6, 2025 in the program First Question of Telemundomoderated by Rafael Lenin Lopez.
“That person (Veronica Lugo), the defense is in the interest of, at the time, presenting her as a witness. At that same moment, the same controversy will arise, judge, but at this time we have to demonstrate the manifestations,” argued attorney Alberto Rivera Ramosone of Cabrera Rivera’s lawyers.
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
Given this, Barreto Altieri immediately responded that the evidence had to be heard first before resolving any controversy over its admissibility.
“We are going to bring the witness, ask the questions so I know and avoid surprises before a jury and I determine. That is what Rule 109 is for. Don’t argue with me, we go to the proof and based on the proof, the arguments are made,” said Barreto Altieri.
For its part, the prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto -who together with the prosecutors Myriam Nieves and Jackeline Pizarro representing the Public Ministry – argued that the admissibility of the evidence had to be determined first.
“The witness, when determined according to the evidence, judge, will establish whether she is made available (to the defense) and they will determine (then whether they would use her in the judicial process),” he indicated.
Rivera Ramos then responded that the defense had litigated the case based on the information it knew up to that point. “We are litigating this case assuming that what was told to us is…” he began to say, before being interrupted by the judge.
“I am not going to resolve something that you have not resolved yet. When it is presented to the court in a stipulation, or if there is a provision, I am going to resolve it. We are going to test with this witness, we are going to Rule 109 because we are already entering into the controversy,” Barreto Altieri replied.
Immediately afterwards, Rivera Ramos began his line of questions to the investigating agent. Angel Torres Romeroof the Homicide Division of the Criminal Investigation Corps (CIC) of Aibonito.
“Look, witness, I ask you if you were aware that on August 19, agent Veronica Lugo interviewed a social worker from the Department of Family to Anthonieska,” he questioned.
Then, the witness said: “Yes, I found out later.”
The lawyer continued: “I ask you if you found out later as part of the investigative efforts you made?”
“Correct,” the witness replied.
1/9 | “Meeting for peace”: Aibonitenos carry out a march and vigil after violent incidents. Hundreds of people marched at the “Meeting for Peace” in Aibonito, in a call from the Parish of Aibonito to end acts of violence. – Supplied
Rivera Ramos then continued with the line of questions. “Do you know that agent Veronica Lugo gave Miranda warnings to Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera, co-accused in this process? Do you know that even after the Miranda warnings were given, the young Anthonieska Aviles decided to make demonstrations? Do you know the demonstrations that she made?” he said.
Then he asked the central question: “I ask you if you agree with me that these statements exonerate Mrs. Elvia Cabrera?”
The prosecutor immediately objected, maintaining that it was reference evidence. However, Barreto Altieri indicated that he would first listen to the content of the alleged demonstrations to determine if they could be admitted.
However, before the argument continued, the defense chose to withdraw the entire line of questioning.
“We are going to withdraw that line of questions because the prosecutor has not said whether she is going to seat Agent Veronica Lugo or not. We are withdrawing the entire line of questions because we just found out today that Agent Veronica Lugo still does not know if she is going to sit down,” said Rivera Ramos.
Once the discussion of the evidence concluded, the judge ordered the jurors to return to the room to resume the proceedings and the electronic transmission of the case continued.
However, the controversy did not end there. The defense attempted to question the witness about a complaint that former prosecutor Orlando Velazquez allegedly filed against him. The Prosecutor’s Office objected to the line of questioning, and the judge declared the objection “acceptable,” so the statement was removed from the record.
Then, the lawyer requested a reconsideration, insisting that Velazquez made “a claim (to the witness) precisely because of his investigative efforts,” to which the judge replied that “if there is no complaint adjudicated, there is no place, the question is not allowed.”
