The Parole Board (JLBP) defended its processes in the face of the accusations made in relation to the case of Carlos Estefano Pino, a convicted suspect of the murder of nurse Jennifer Torres Castro, in Caguasin June.
Through a written communication, the entity expressed solidarity with the victims, while ensuring that it acted in accordance with Law number 118 of 1974, which created the JLBP.
“This Board subsequently carried out a thorough review of the administrative file and, from the evidence contained in said file, information emerged that reflected compliance with the objective criteria applicable in accordance with the Law, for the continuity of the privilege granted”indicates the letter, where it was also clarified that the current composition of the JLBP was not the one that issued the determination to grant Estefano Pino parole.
However, the entity recognizes that certain aspects of the law could be improved.
“The experience derived from this and other cases proves the importance of evaluating possible amendments to current legislation that allow us to further strengthen the evaluation process of candidates for parole, incorporating additional tools for risk assessment and protection of public safety without undermining the guarantees of due process of law,” the statement says.
Likewise, the JLBP indicated that it would not elaborate on the case so as not to hinder the ongoing administrative investigations.
“The Board will not issue judgments or conclusions on facts whose evaluation corresponds to the competent authorities. However, it maintains its absolute willingness to collaborate with any official investigation and provide all the information that is required in accordance with the current legal system,” the statement said.
The letter also explains that the JLBP’s determinations are not made automatically nor do they respond to arbitrary criteria.
“Each case is evaluated in an individualized, rigorous manner and in accordance with the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, Law No. 118 of July 22, 1974, as amended, and the Regulations for the Consideration of Parole Cases”he prays.
The facts
According to the Uniformed Police, the nurse’s death was classified as murder after the ICF evaluation, which found that the victim had bruises on her face. Initially, the case was reported as a death “without a determined cause.”
1 / 6 | In images: this is how a “person of interest” was arrested for the murder of a nurse in Caguas. A 67-year-old man was arrested as a “person of interest” in relation to the death of a woman in Caguas. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
The events occurred on June 24 in a residence located in the Rio Canas neighborhood, Quebrada Arenas sector, in Caguas, where the lifeless body of Torres Castro, who was the mother of two girls, ages 10 and 12, was found.
Estefano Pino was arrested last week in Barceloneta by personnel from the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (DCR), after being identified as a person of interest in the investigation into the death of Torres Castro.
About his freedom on parole
Estefano Pino had been released in 2018 by the JLBP, when he still had 85 years left on his sentence for the murder of Myrna Baez Vallea 22-year-old girl, occurred in 1990.
The president of the JLBP, Samuel Silva Rosasshared last Wednesday with The New Day that They had ordered the arrest of the man after being “suspected of a murder”despite the fact that he complied with the adjustment plan, he went to his annual hearings and no complaint had been filed against him.
In a statement issued this Tuesday, the JLBP stated that The current composition of the Board was not the one that originally granted the privilege of parole to Estefano Pino.
However, it indicated that, after a subsequent review of the administrative file, information emerged that reflected compliance with the objective criteria applicable for the continuity of the privilege.
The Board also reiterated that parole “does not extinguish the sentence imposed by a court”but constitutes a privilege subject to compliance with specific conditions, continuous DCR supervision and possible revocation.
Furthermore, the JLBP maintained that it will not pass judgment on facts that correspond to the investigative authorities, but stated that This and other cases reflect the importance of evaluating possible amendments to current legislation to strengthen the evaluation process of candidates for parole.including additional tools to assess risk and protect public safety.
From 2025, The Board has granted 166 parole privileges, of which 71—equivalent to 42.8%—correspond to people convicted of murder in any of its forms.according to the statement.
