Hamden, Ohio— Just a few days after authorities rescued 16 children from a home in precarious conditions and detained four adult relatives, a question looms over this town in southern Mexico. Ohio: How could this happen, for years, without anyone noticing, right here?
The family’s neighbors in the small town of Hamden, employees at the local stores where they shopped, and even investigators who responded to the scene have wondered about that question, both out loud and internally, and the scant information provided by investigators does not offer a complete answer.
The children were not enrolled in any school, the family had moved several times in the last two decades, and neighbors claimed they had never seen the children. According to investigators, the children were almost always kept in a small room in the house, in deplorable conditions.
“Right under our noses and no one was able to help them before,” said Emily Collins, 27, owner of VC Farm & Floral in nearby McArthur. “It’s crazy that, with all the wonderful things happening in our little picture-postcard town, this is what puts us in the spotlight. It’s really sad,” said the mother of three, who was moved to decorate the sidewalk with brightly colored flowers and chalk stars to cheer herself up a little.
“We have to let the case take its course”
The authorities stated that they had gone to the home on Tuesday as part of an investigation unrelated to this case and that there they found the children – between one and a half years old and 18 years old – some of whom could not speak.
Seven people were taken to hospitals, including one who was in critical condition, investigators said. His current status was still unknown on Thursday. Child protective services have temporary custody of children.
A man who lives three doors down from the Siders family said he “hadn’t seen any children” there.
“It’s a sad situation,” said Joseph Stewart, 60, who has lived in this “quiet neighborhood” for six years.
Four people – the children’s parents and grandparents – were arrested on charges of endangering minors. Gary Siders Jr., 36; Gary Siders, 73; Elizabeth Siders, 33, and Christina Siders, 67, pleaded not guilty to child endangerment. Bail was set at $300,000 for each.
A lawyer for Mr. Siders, the older of the two, said he is presumed innocent.
“While it is virtually impossible to prevent unfounded speculation, conjecture or assumptions from arising, I would ask everyone to let the process take its course, regardless of the sensational nature of the allegations against Mr. Siders,” said Dorian Baum.
Attorneys for Siders Jr. and Christina Siders declined to comment. Messages to Elizabeth Siders’ attorney seeking comment were not immediately returned.
Little traffic on the country road leading to the house
Authorities have not wanted to publicly reveal the nature of the other investigation that led them to the home on Tuesday. However, court records show that an arrest warrant was issued that same day for Siders Jr. on a misdemeanor charge of indecent exposure related to alleged incidents that occurred over four days in May. He has pleaded not guilty.
By Thursday, the windows and doors of the previously open house, located about 60 miles southeast of Columbus, had been boarded up. There was still police tape and piles of trash.
The day before, there was a door ajar and, inside, piles of garbage and children’s toys were visible. The wooden deck and backyard were littered with discarded tires, a high chair and other debris.

The house is located on a road next to a steep railway embankment, where the tracks lead the trains, with their rumble, to a marshalling station located in the town, which has less than 1,000 inhabitants. The nearest neighbors are separated by trees and thick undergrowth, but the house is perfectly visible from the road.
They didn’t go to school
Investigators said family members had moved around southern Ohio over the past two decades and had apparently avoided leaving a medical or administrative trail. The Vinton County Local School District, the only one in the area, stated that it has no records indicating that any of the children were ever enrolled.
“These people were pretty good at hiding these kids,” Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson said Wednesday.
The children’s absence from school and the apparent lack of regular visits to health professionals likely contributed to this serious situation going unnoticed, said Jacqueline Yahn, an associate professor at Ohio University.
“When children are isolated or not participating, there is no one with the training to spot the signs,” said Yahn, a rural education and poverty specialist. “The well-being assessment is called that for a reason: it is about checking the well-being and development of children.”
Investigators were checking to see if the family had been the subject of any complaints to a child protection agency in the past.
The children spent most of their time in a room that measured about 12 feet by 12 feet, according to investigators, who noted that there was human waste everywhere.
“They looked almost like wild animals. It was terrible,” Wilson said.
