
A U.S. judge on Tuesday barred the federal government from making arrests in immigration courts, ordering an end to a practice that took hold shortly after President Donald Trump took office last year.
The Trump administration’s reversal of a long-standing policy of not making arrests in immigration courts was due “not simply to unreasoned decision-making, but to a complete absence of decision-making,” wrote federal Judge Casey Pitts of San Francisco. Authorities did not address the “deterrent effect” of arrests on people required to attend court hearings.
“For 80 years, Congress has directed federal agencies to think before acting,” Pitts wrote, referring to the Administrative Procedure Act, a 1946 law that requires federal agencies to justify their actions. That law, he wrote, “does not require an agency to make a decision that a reviewing court might deem preferable. But it does require an agency to at least offer solid reasons for pursuing the course it chose to pursue.”
It is the second setback for court arrests since May, when a federal judge in New York banned them in immigration courts. That order applied only in New York, while the most recent decision invalidated the policy nationwide.
James Percival, legal director of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), criticized the ruling as a judicial overreach.
“When a judge convicts a defendant, the defendant is taken into custody. If an immigration judge orders the removal of an alien, the same should happen. For a district judge to order otherwise is blatant judicial activism in service of an anti-American open borders agenda,” Percival wrote online.
After Trump took office, hearings across the country often ended with cases dismissed by the government, setting the stage for plainclothes agents to make hallway arrests, coordinating with DHS lawyers.
Pitts, who was appointed by former President Joe Biden, faulted the government for carrying out the arrests and holding people in nearby cells for longer than the prescribed 12-hour limit.
This story was translated from English to Spanish with an artificial intelligence tool and was reviewed by an editor before publication.
