Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – The night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, when she was stabbed to death Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, Elvia Cabrera Rivera She reached into her purse, took out a punch with her right hand and handed it to her daughter. Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera.
This was stated under oath. Leshandra Pesante Rodriguezwitness #18 of the Public Ministry, who testified on the nineteenth day of the jury trial against Cabrera Rivera, accused of the murder of the teenager, affectionately nicknamed “Lela.”
Pesante Rodriguez, who this Wednesday became the most important witness of the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office in this case by ensuring that she was the person who held the wallet from which the accused took the sharp object, revealed in Room 1 what she remembers from that night.
In a heartbreaking testimony, which caused the victim’s mother Lisandra Rosario Berrios began to cry and had to leave the hearing for minutes, the 31-year-old woman explained how the accused allegedly helped her daughter carry out the crime.
She explained that on August 10 she was enjoying the Great Municipal Summer Closing with her friend, Bethsaida Carattini Ortizto whom he calls “titi”. He reported that, subsequently, they continued to share between the businesses El Maestro Liquor Store and La Placita Martinez.
Some time later, Aviles Cabrera, along with her half-sister and her best friend, Miriathny Aviles Cabrera and Gabriela “Gaba” Figueroa Arroyorespectively, joined the group, while the atmosphere little by little began to change due to differences between sisters.
Like other witnesses, he stated that the genesis of the confrontation was the romantic relationship that Miriathny had with Karelin Plata Diazwho apparently was not accepted. That led to Miriathny and her sister Faviola getting into an argument that ended with blows.
Pesante Rodriguez indicated that, at one point, he noticed that the defendant and her other daughter Anthiany arrived at the detour area. He explained that they came down from the El Maestro Liquor Store business. “She (Elvia) arrived upset and asked what was happening,” he stressed.
The witness narrated how the atmosphere continued to escalate to the point where the accused allegedly rummaged through her purse and took out a punch which she handed to her daughter. His story unfolded under the gaze of everyone present in the room, including the jury.
“I saw that Elvia was rummaging through her purse, which was large, rectangular, like a dark khaki color and the edge was creamy orange. The purse was open. She took out a punch. I was three feet away. She passed it to her daughter Antho,” mentioned Pesante Rodriguez.
1/8 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
During the interrogation carried out by prosecutor Myriam Nieves Vera, the witness explained that the accused took out the punch with her right hand. He claimed that the awl was pointed, sharp, approximately an inch wide. “The tip was sharp,” he emphasized.
When the prosecutor asked what the defendant did with her wallet, Pesante Rodriguez responded: “She put it in my hands. I was shocked. I kept thinking about what’s happening here. She’s leaving for the riot. They were on top of each other.”
The witness insisted that she stayed in the same place, because she was completely in shock. “What was happening here was happening. I had the wallet in my right hand. After that, I noticed that Lela (the victim’s nickname) was lying on the floor,” he mentioned.
“(Lela) was lying on the floor, on the road. She was face up. She had her arms outstretched. I threw the purse on the grass and ran to where ‘Lela’ was. I fell to the floor and grabbed her arm to feel her pulse. She had no pulse. She was cold,” the witness said in the courtroom.
At that moment, the victim’s mother, who was sobbing in the room, left the hearing for a few minutes, while the witness continued narrating what she remembers from that night. He noted that the victim had a black dress, which was “a little raised.”
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
“Her friends came, one of them took down her suit. I was telling her to take her. They grabbed her and took her away. They put her in Dylan’s car and my titi Bethsaida was telling mom (Lisandra) to get in the vehicle,” said Pesante Rodriguez.
At that time, he indicated, the victim was transported in said vehicle. “I stayed because I was with Papucho’s brother, Chrisangel (the victim’s best friend). He was dizzy, he was screaming that it hurt. Bethsaida and I went to him,” he said.
He said that the minor, 17 years old, lifted his coat, which was full of blood. “He had a tear on the back of his neck. He was bleeding a lot. After that, Elvia turned to look for her wallet. I was finishing fighting with Chrisangel. She put a cloth on him,” he said.
He also assured that the accused “was trying to explain what happened between the girls.” “She wanted to talk, but she didn’t speak,” commented the witness, who indicated that she walked behind the accused until she reached the El Maestro business, where the owner asked her if everything was okay.
“I was waiting for Titi Bethsaida to ask a friend if she could take us to the (Mennonite) hospital. She was in a car that was by El Maestro. She asked if she could take her to the hospital. She asked me if I was going home or to the hospital. I told her no, that I was going to the hospital. I got in,” the witness commented when asked by the prosecutor.
1 / 5 | Outside the court: relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts demand justice. Relatives of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario arrived at the Aibonito Court to demand justice. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
Instead, he stated that the defendant, her two daughters and Figueroa Arroyo remained in the El Maestro business. Then, he reported that, upon arriving at the hospital, he found the victim’s mother “lying on the floor.” “He told us that the baby had arrived dead,” he said.
Likewise, Pesante Rodriguez asserted that at the medical institution he told Reynaldo Fernandez Maldonado, the boyfriend of Lismary Torres Rosario, the victim’s older sister. “That I had seen Elvia take something out of her purse and pass it to her daughter,” he insisted.
To reinforce the witness’s statement, the Public Ministry used film evidence, mainly recordings from the security cameras of an establishment near La Placita Martinez and others from an area near the Roberto Colon detour, in Aibonito.
The testimony took place in the presence of relatives of both the victim and the accused. Zorimar Betancourt and Johanna Ortiz, mothers of Stefano Steenbakkers Betancourt and Lara Camila Gonzalez Ortiz, respectively, were also present.
As a summary, Steenbakkers Betancourt was fatally shot in June 2012 in the middle of a “carjacking” on PR-693 in Dorado. Meanwhile, Gonzalez Ortiz died during a traffic accident in September 2023 in Vega Baja.
1 / 6 | Evidence in images: the raid on Elvia Cabrera’s house. The Police executed a search and seizure warrant at the residence of the accused, Elvia Cabrera Rivera. – Judiciary
Defense cross-examination
At the end of the turn of the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office, the lawyer Yancarlos Maisonet Hernandezone of the defense attorneys, began the cross-examination, emphasizing discrepancies between the courtroom testimony and the witness’s sworn statement.
One of the discrepancies was that, contrary to what she stated in court, the witness did not say in her sworn statement, which she gave on August 15, 2025, that Cabrera Rivera arrived at the detour upset. Furthermore, Pesante Rodriguez acknowledged that when Cabrera Rivera took out the sharp object, no fight had occurred.
The lawyer also told the witness that she suffers from myopia and astigmatism, visual conditions that can make it difficult to see up close or far away, inferring that, even when she was at a short distance, it was possible that she had not observed what happened because of this.
They do not admit declaration
Earlier, the Public Ministry called its witness #17 in the case to testify: the agent Veronica Lugo Riverawho worked for the Youth Affairs Office, in the Aibonito Command, during the date on which the murder of the teenager occurred.
Lugo Rivera stated that he read to Aviles Cabrera the “Miranda Warnings for suspected persons in custody,” which contain the constitutional rights that protect every citizen, including that they can remain silent and not answer questions.
Lugo Rivera confirmed that her intervention with Aviles Cabrera occurred on August 19, 2025, when she was taken to his office. In his presence, Aviles Cabrera filled out the “Suspected Person Declaration,” where he wrote: “My mother and sister were not involved.”
However, the statement was part of a debate raised under Rule 109 of Evidence, with the jury absent from the courtroom. After hearing the arguments of both parties, Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri determined that it was not admitted as evidence.
