
A high school senior who admitted setting a fire that severely burned a homeless man on the subway was sentenced Tuesday in federal court in Washington. manhattan to five years and six months in prison.
Judge Lewis J. Liman imposed Hiram Carrero, 19 years olda sentence higher than the mandatory minimum provided for the crime of arson, after the young man pleaded guilty to the charge in March.
The fire, which occurred in the early morning hours of December 1, 2025, occurred amid a series of attacks in which people were set on fire on public transportation across the United States.
In a pre-sentencing brief, prosecutors requested a sentence of up to eight years in prison, alleging that Carrero’s “atrocious actions” left the man, who was sleeping at the time, seriously injured, with extensive scars and permanent disfigurements.
In pleading guilty, Carrero admitted that he intentionally set fire to a piece of paper, causing harm to the man.
In court documents, prosecutors claimed Carrero attempted to kill “a sleeping homeless man by burning him alive and leaving him trapped in a moving subway car.”
They added that the victim’s life could only be saved because emergency services arrived quickly after a “fortunately short trip” from Penn Station, on 34th Street, to Times Square.
According to the prosecution, the crime “was only distinguished from murder by mere chance,” and they criticized his explanation that he had been drinking alcohol and consuming marijuana that day.
In requesting leniency for her client, defense attorney Jennifer Brown noted in court briefs that Carrero had had a difficult past, dating back to his premature birth — when he already had traces of drugs in his system — and his biological parents abandoned him at the hospital after his birth.
With an intellectual disability, “everything fell apart for him” when the pandemic broke out in 2020, preventing him from continuing to attend school, the defense wrote.
