Study Provides “Strong Evidence” That COVID-19 Is a Seasonal Infection

Study Provides “Strong Evidence” That COVID-19 Is a Seasonal Infection

A new study led by the Barcelona Institute for Global Health (ISGlobal), a center supported by the “la Caixa” Foundation, has provided “solid evidence” that COVID-19 is a seasonal infection associated with low temperature and humidity, similar to seasonal influenza.

The results, published in the journal ‘Nature Computational Science’, also underline the considerable contribution of aerosol transmission and the need for measures to promote “air hygiene”.

A key question regarding SARS-CoV-2 is whether it is behaving or will behave as a seasonal virus similar to the influenza virus, or whether it will be transmitted with the same intensity throughout the year.

An early study with theoretical models suggested that weather was not an important factor, given the large number of susceptible people with no prior immunity to the virus. However, some observations suggested that the initial spread of the virus in China occurred at a latitude between 30 and 50oN, with low humidity levels and temperatures (between 5o and 11oC).

“The question of whether COVID-19 is a truly seasonal disease is becoming increasingly important, with implications for the implementation of effective interventions,” explains Xavier Rodó, director of ISGlobal’s Climate and Health program and coordinator of the study.

To answer this question, he and his team first analyzed the association of temperature and humidity in the early phase of virus spread in 162 countries on five continents, before changes in behavior and public health policies were implemented.

The results show a negative correlation between transmission rate (Ro) and global temperature and humidity: higher transmission rates were associated with lower temperatures and humidity.

Second, the team analyzed the evolution of this association between climate and disease over time, and whether it was consistent at different geographical scales. To do this, they used a statistical method that was specifically designed to identify similar patterns of variation (i.e., a pattern recognition tool) in different time windows.

Again, they found a strong negative association for small time windows between number of cases and climate (temperature and humidity), with consistent patterns during the first, second and third waves of the pandemic and at different spatial scales: globally, by country, by region in heavily affected countries (Lombardy, Thüringen, Catalonia), and even at the city level (Barcelona).

The first pandemic waves decreased as temperature and humidity increased, and the second wave increased as temperature and humidity decreased. However, this pattern broke down during the summer, on all continents. “This could be due to several factors, including massive concentrations of young people, tourism, and air conditioning, among others,” notes Alejandro Fontal, ISGlobal researcher and first author of the study.

When the model was adapted to analyze transient correlations at all scales in countries in the southern hemisphere, where the virus arrived later, the same negative correlation was observed. The effects of climate were most evident at temperatures between 12o and 18oC and humidity levels between 4 and 12 g/m3, although the research team cautions that these are indicative ranges, due to the limited time of records.

Finally, using an epidemiological model, the study shows that incorporating temperature into the transmission rate works best for predicting the rise and fall of different waves, particularly the first and third waves in Europe. “Our results as a whole support the idea that COVID-19 is a truly seasonal infection, similar to influenza and the other common cold coronaviruses,” Rodó notes.

This seasonality could be an important contributor to SARS-CoV-2 transmission, as low humidity conditions reduce aerosol size and thus increase airborne transmission of seasonal viruses such as influenza.

“This association justifies placing emphasis on “air hygiene” through better ventilation of indoor spaces, as aerosols can remain suspended for longer,” concludes Rodó, who stresses the need to include meteorological parameters in the planning and evaluation of control measures.