After 10 years of the Promesa law, the main balance for the municipalities has been the elimination of the Equalization Fund –which deprived almost half of them of a substantial source of resources–, as well as the establishment of new dynamics in their relationship with the State.
The new supervision model, however, has lacked operational restructuring mechanisms and oversight tools that promote true fiscal disciplineagreed mayors and former municipal executives interviewed.
“They (the Fiscal Supervision Board, JSF) needed to show a little interest in, first, knowing what the financial structure of the municipalities was like and what the purpose was, let’s say, of the Equalization Fund, which was eliminated. They never understood what the purpose of the Equalization Fund was“, said the former New Progressive mayor of Cidra Javier Carrasquillo.
He recalled that the former governor Ricardo Rossello Nevares included, in the first fiscal plan certified by the Board, the elimination of the Equalization Fund, a pot of money distributed among municipalities based on their economic needs and which was gradually eliminated from 2017 until June 30, 2024.
It was fed by different items, including 2.5% that the State transferred from net internal revenues, 35% of the net income of the Electronic Lottery and a portion of the basic property tax of each municipality. These last two items are the ones that continue to be distributed by the Municipal Revenue Collection Center (CRIM). At its peak, the Fund redistributed more than $350 million annually.
Precisely, when the elimination of the Fund began, Carrasquillo presided over the CRIM Governing Board, and in his opinion, The members of the Board “seemed not to understand that the Equalization Fund was one of justice for those municipalities that – due to their geographical location and social conditions – do not have the same development potential as the municipalities where all the government’s economic activity is focused.
Although the Promesa law was designed in Congress to deal with the bankruptcy of the central government, the municipalities were impacted as of May 9, 2019, when the Board designated them as entities covered under the federal statute.
The financial control entity devised a pilot plan in which the municipalities of Aibonito, Barranquitas, Camuy, Cidra, Comerio, Isabela, Orocovis, Quebradillas, San Sebastian and Villalba participated. Each town was required to prepare and deliver fiscal plans that included expense reductions and efficiency measures, while the Board offered technical assistance. However, this project had no substantive effects.
“Exactly, there are 37 municipalities that lost more than 40% of the budget with the elimination of the Equalization Fund. The municipalities that lost the most are those with the highest poverty rate in the country”said the former mayor of Comerio and now popular senator Jose “Josian” Santiago.
He affirmed that these municipalities were kept alive by federal aid due to emergencies such as hurricanes Irma and Maria, in 2017, as well as COVID-19, in 2020, and State lifelines that are not recurring.
However, once this assistance has ended, there are already municipalities in trouble, Santiago and the mayor of Coamo pointed out. Juan Carlos Garcia Padilla. According to CRIM data, Arroyo, Ciales, Florida, Guayanilla, Las Marias and Maricao have been facing economic problems since last year.
In attending to municipal affairs, the Board, under the then executive direction of Natalie Jareskoconcluded that the town councils had an inadequate financial structure, extreme dependence on the State and systemic problems because some did not generate enough income of their own.
From those times until today, now under the direction of Robert Mujicathe Board transformed the dynamic between the State and the municipalities: financing is conditional, the consolidation of services is promoted, and allocations are for emergencies or necessary services.
Among the initiatives that evidence this change is the annulment, by the Board, of Law 29 of 2019, which sought to exempt municipal governments from paying pensions, known as “PayGo”, and the contribution to the central government health card.
“The result of Promesa was to restructure the debt and state finances and be detrimental to the municipal ones. Even so, they do not take away the economic burden that we have of the 1.03% that is from the State Debt Redemption Fund to pay the central government bonds. We continue to give a portion to the State. That is the impact of Promesa,” said Garcia Padilla, of the Popular Democratic Party (PPD), who strongly advocates decentralization.
In the opinion of Luis Roberto Rivera Cruzwho was commissioner of the defunct Office of the Commissioner of Municipal Affairs (OCAM) and then manager of the pilot program of municipalities for the Board, this initiative that was undertaken helped to better understand the particularities of the municipalities. But he acknowledged that there is still an agenda that “has been postponed.”
“Certainly, a decentralization agenda that has been promoted for decades has been postponed, and precisely for this reason the Law of Autonomous Municipalities was approved and later reformed in the Municipal Code. seeking to make the central government transfer certain powers, certain functions, certain services to the municipalities, understanding that the municipalities can do it better than the central government”explained Rivera Cruz.
The mayor of Coamo highlighted, for his part, that, in April 2017, months after its creation, the Board approved the plan for the liquidation of the Government Development Bank (GDB) and, with it, municipalities lost the main borrowing entity and access to their own savings. The BGF was replaced by the Financial Advisory and Fiscal Agency Authority (Aafaf), which established an adjustment process that left some municipalities without debt and others had it significantly reduced.
Subsequently, in June 2017, by law and as a consequence of Promesa, the OCAM was eliminated.
Despite the collapse of the GDB and the establishment of a new operating system, the responsibility of the municipalities to contribute to the State debt was maintained and payment of their loans one year in advance was established, which now must be with private banks, supervised by the Aafaf and with the guarantee of the Board.
“In the case of municipalities, we continue to pay our debt. It is the only debt that continues to be paid to the guy, without any discount. There has been no restructuring for the municipalities. It’s urgent. Right now, the State continues to spend more. But the vast majority of the dramatic social responsibilities that the country has, right now, are assumed by us,” Garcia Padilla emphasized.
The former mayor of San Sebastian Javier Jimenezwho fought the validity of the Promesa law on municipalities, said that “a total restructuring of municipal operations must be carried out.” “We, as a territory, have to understand that the path that Puerto Rico is on again is towards collapse,” said the former municipal executive, elected by the New Progressive Party but today a member of Proyecto Dignidad.
Jimenez and Carrasquillo described, respectively, as a “failure” and “failed attempt” the application of Promesa to the municipalities. They recalled that, in 2021, the Board created the Municipal Services Consolidation Fund, to promote the creation of consortia between municipalities to reduce operational costs, and even the $66 million it contains remain intact.
“In theory, it sounded good. In practice, it is a bit complex”said Carrasquillo.
Meanwhile, the New Progressive mayor of Orocovis, Jesus Colon Berlingerisaid that, after the Board eliminated, in April 2021, the pilot project on the municipalities, it chose to focus on the CRIM, from which it requires a fiscal plan.
He highlighted that the CRIM gives the Board limited “visibility” of the municipalities.
“We have what the debts are, mostly statutory, that is, the loans. But the possible debt that municipalities have with any agency is not processed through the CRIM. It is the municipality’s option to pay it through the CRIM or not to pay it,” said Colon Berlingeri.
Those interviewed, with the exception of Carrasquillo and Santiago, understand that, after the elimination of the OCAM, it is necessary to establish a supervisory body for the municipalities.
“The first thing that has to be created is mandatory fiscal discipline. That’s the first thing. And how do they force them? Easy. You cannot give funds to a municipality to administer when it has exhibited a lack of administrative capacity”Jimenez stated.
