:format(jpeg):focal(2329x1508:2339x1498)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/ZU2CQWDZ2VACHPCJVSBPRSEDNE.jpg)
Two months after the trial, the federal prosecutor’s office defended the indictment presented by a grand jury against the former representative of the New Progressive Party (PNP). Maria Milagros “Tata” Charbonier on corruption charges.
The Public Ministry also presented its opposition to the request that the defendants in that case have separate trials and that charges be dismissed, assuring that they have sufficient evidence to prove them.
The arguments are contained in a series of motions filed before the federal court by the federal prosecutor in Puerto Rico, Maria Montanez, together with Jonathan Jacobson and Kathryn Fifield, prosecutors from the Office of Public Integrity of the federal Department of Justice in New York.
“Facing a 26-page indictment that provides a detailed road map that defines the charges against her, Maria Milagros Charbonier Laureano argues” in a motion that the prosecution “has not been sufficiently detailed,” the prosecution indicates. “She’s wrong.”
In relation to the “honest services” fraud charges, the statement “contains much more than the statutory allegations that would have sufficed here,” for which reason he requested that Charbonier’s request for the indictment be dismissed.
He stressed that the 50 paragraphs of the statement relate that Charbonier “formulated a scheme to defraud the Government of Puerto Rico through bribes and illegal commissions by fraudulently inflating the salary of his employee in exchange for the agreement with the employee to make biweekly payments to Charbonier.” .
It added that “Charbonier executed the scheme by means of false and fraudulent claims, representations and promises” and caused “various electronic communications to be transmitted to promote the scheme.”
He also requested to deny a motion by Charbonier’s son, Orlando Montes Charbonier, who argues that the prosecution has not presented sufficient evidence to prove the charges against him.
“An indictment is only an allegation. You do not need to present enough evidence to prove the case of the Public Ministry ”, raises a motion by prosecutors. “Their role is to inform defendants of the charges they face and the specific conduct in question.”
Similarly, the prosecutors filed a third motion in which they stated their reasons for opposing the request that Montes Charbonier and his father, Orlando Montes Riveraso that their trials are separated from those of the former representative.
“There are compelling reasons for a joint trial in this case”indicated the prosecutors, noting that “the four defendants participated in a single conspiracy.”
They also said they will use “essentially” the same evidence against all four defendants, including Charbonier’s former employee, Frances Acevedo.
In addition, they argued that “there is no indication that any of the defenses here are antagonistic” between the defendants.
The trial against the four defendants is scheduled to begin with the selection of the jury from October 23, in the room of Judge Silvia Carreno Coll, in the Federal Court in Hato Rey.
Charbonier was arrested on August 17, 2020. The sheet issued by a grand jury includes 13 federal charges.
According to the accusation, in early 2017, the former PNP legislator inflated the salary of Acevedo Ceballos, who was her assistant on the House of Representatives Legal Committee, from $800 to $2,100. Then in September 2019 she raised the salary again to $2,900.
The indictment alleges that the two agreed that, after inflating her salary, Acevedo would pay a kickback to Charbonier, her husband and son, in a form of bribery. The prosecution estimated that Charbonier received $100,000 during the period of the alleged conspiracy, beginning in September 2017.
