:format(jpeg):focal(2275x2085:2285x2075)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/JBNFWGLZ4NAWRAG5JLE7HJL6UU.jpg)
New Orleans — The President’s Government Joe Biden asked a federal appeals court Monday to temporarily block a lower court order limiting executive branch officials’ discussions with social media companies about controversial online posts.
The request for the emergency injunction was filed at the Federal Court of Appeals of the 5th Circuit shortly after District Judge Terry Doughty denied the government’s motion to stay the order he himself had issued on July 4.
The order stems from a lawsuit filed by the attorneys general of Louisiana and Missouri, both Republicans, as well as the owner of a conservative website and four individuals critical of government policies related to COVID-19.
The lawsuit claimed that the government was effectively censoring free speech by threatening regulatory action while pressuring companies to remove what it deemed disinformation. Vaccines against COVID-19, legal issues surrounding Hunter Biden — the president’s son — and accusations of voter fraud were some of the issues highlighted in the lawsuit.
Doughty was nominated for the position by former President Donald Trump. His order prohibits the Department of Health and Human Services, the FBI, and other government agencies from meeting with or contacting social media companies for the purpose of “in any way encouraging, pressuring, or inducing the removal, deletion, suppression or reduction of content protected by freedom of expression”.
Government lawyers noted in their motion in court for the 5th Circuit that Doughty’s ruling was too general and vague, and opened up the possibility of limiting speech by government officials on important issues. They further noted that Doughty did not mention any evidence that the government had threatened social media companies to coerce them to remove the posts.
“The district court did not identify any evidence to suggest that any request to remove the content was accompanied by a threat. In fact, the order denying the suspension—presumably highlighting the strongest evidence—referred to ‘a series of public statements in the press’”the government noted.
They asked that the 5th Circuit court block Doughty’s order while the New Orleans appeals court case proceeds, or at the very least, grant the order a 10-day stay so the government can prepare to go to the Supreme Court for a longer stay.
