Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – The trial against Elvia Cabrera Riveraaccused of the murder of the minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old, This Wednesday entered its 22nd day, with the final arguments before the jury that will have the responsibility of issuing a verdict.
From the Room 1 of the Aibonito Court, before Superior Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieriso much the Public Ministry as the defense They presented their respective theories of the case and They asked the panel of citizens to evaluate the evidence presented during these months.
Closing arguments represent the last opportunity for the parties to address the jury before the case moves to the deliberation phase, which culminates when the 12 members – seven women and four men – issue the verdict.
During the process, the Prosecutor’s Office presented 61 witnesses as part of its theory of the case, of which 21 testified in person before the court. Among them were witnesses who witnessed the attack on August 10, 2025, at the Roberto Colon detour.
The Public Ministry maintained during the trial that Cabrera Rivera and his daughter, Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraacted in common and mutual agreement in the attack against Pratts Rosario. Both face two charges of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law.
Before the 12 members of the jury – seven women and five men – the prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto He began his final arguments by summarizing the accusations that the accused faces for the crime that has shocked the so-called “City of Flowers.”
Standing in front of the podium and looking directly at the jury, Rubio Barreto maintained that, through the testimonies, the security camera recordings and the photographs presented during the trial, the Prosecutor’s Office sought to demonstrate its theory of the case.
“None of the decision you make will be able to bring Gabriela Nicole back to life, but you will be able to give her justice according to the law. That night (August 10), Gabriela Nicole acted to defend her sister (Lismary Torres),” the prosecutor mentioned.
He added that the victim was attacked by Aviles Cabrera, after his mother “fueled that violence,” looking for the “sharp object” with which they allegedly took the victim’s life. “Elvia gave the object to her daughter,” he stressed.
“Gabriela Nicole lost her life because the violence escalated because of this lady, Elvia Cabrera Rivera,” added Rubio Barreto. “It was a decision made by these two people (Elvia and Anthonieska), who had the intention to kill.”
He pointed out that the murder occurred because “a mother, an adult, who had the duty to stop that violence (on the Roberto Colon detour), encouraged it. “Elvia was not a mere spectator that night, her participation was active and she delivered the object.”
Likewise, he insisted that this act was what caused the victim’s death, since the accused gave the murder weapon to her daughter and gave her a tacit instruction, “which was understood by her daughter (Anthonieska): take the weapon and go kill.”
Then, the prosecutor focused her argument on the testimonies that she considered core. He explained that these not only support that the accused allegedly gave the murder weapon to her daughter, but also indicate that she tried to influence and intimidate witnesses.
Rubio Barreto recalled that, according to the autopsy performed by the pathologist Javier Gustavo Serranothe victim had 11 wounds. She argued that the nature of these injuries shows that she was attacked “viciously” and with a “desire to kill,” highlighting that one of the stab wounds directly hit her heart.
“That day, August 10, Elvia Cabrera, instead of protecting her daughter, incited violence; instead of stopping the danger, she fueled it. Today you represent the voice of justice, each and every one of you. This verdict that you are going to issue cannot be based on compassion for the accused; it must be based on the evidence that you heard,” Rubio Barreto indicated in the courtroom.
“Today Gabriela Nicole’s voice cannot be heard, but the voice of justice is in her hands. I, for Gabriela, for the law, for justice and because I represent the people of Puerto Rico, respectfully request that you issue a guilty verdict on each of the charges,” he added during the argument that lasted approximately 40 minutes.
After the conclusion of the arguments, the judge will give final instructions to the jury before the panel – who spent their first night incommunicado after the sequestration order issued by the court – retires to deliberate to reach a verdict.
