Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonite – The judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri, of the Aibonito Courtdeclared “there is no merit” to a request for peremptory acquittal presented by the lawyers of Elvia Cabrera Riveraaccused of the murder of the Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario16 years old, occurred in mid-August 2025 in said municipality.
On July 23, a jury made up of seven women and five men issued a unanimous guilty verdict in the two charges against the accused for the crimes of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law, specifically for the use and/or carrying of a knife.
The same day that the jury issued said verdict, lawyers Mayra Lopez Mulero, Alberto C. Rivera Ramos and Yancarlos Maysonet Hernandez, legal representatives of the accused, presented the request for peremptory acquittal under Rule 135 of Criminal Procedure.
“Rule 135 of Criminal Procedure provides that: ‘The court will decree peremptory acquittal when the evidence is insufficient to support a conviction,’” the lawyers indicated at the beginning of the legal appeal that consists of five pages.
They added that “after more than 20 days of evidence, the Public Prosecutor’s Office was unable to present sufficient direct, scientific or circumstantial evidence to establish that Mrs. Elvia Cabrera Rivera 1) used the murder weapon; 2) delivered the murder weapon; 3) ordered the attack; 4) acted in prior concert with the co-accused Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera; nor 5) intentionally participated in the commission of the charged crime. On the contrary, the entirety of the evidence produced exactly the opposite effect,” the graduates added.
1/11 | 📷 After the verdict, Gabriela Nicole’s relatives return to where everything happened in Aibonito. After a jury found Elvia Cabrera guilty for the murder of Gabrierla Nicole Pratts, the young woman’s relatives went to the Roberto Colon bypass, where the crime occurred in August 2025. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
They insisted that “various eyewitnesses admitted that they never observed Elvia Cabrera Rivera with a weapon; they never saw her take any object out of her purse; they never saw her hand any object to Anthonieska Aviles Cabrera; they never heard instructions to attack; they never observed prior coordination.”
The defense of the accused specified that several witnesses presented by the Public Ministry denied having observed the specific behaviors on which the Public Ministry’s theory of concert and common agreement rests.
Likewise, the lawyers stated that the scientific evidence excluded their client. In this context, they explained that the analyst from the Institute of Forensic Sciences (ICF), Vivina Melendez Velez, confirmed that Cabrera Rivera “was excluded as a DNA donor”, “the (occupied) knife did not produce genetic evidence that linked it”, “the occupied clothing did not link it either” and that “no scientific piece placed it in contact with the weapon or the victim.”
“The only objective evidence presented during the trial did not corroborate the theory of the Public Ministry; on the contrary, it contradicted it. The forensic pathologist, Dr. Javier Serrano Serrano categorically excluded that the murder weapon was half an inch wide as alleged in the accusation,” the lawyers mentioned.
Likewise, they pointed out that the Police investigation into the case was “riddled with omissions,” including that potentially relevant videos were not used, that multiple pieces of DNA were not analyzed, that no fingerprints were collected, that important interviews were not completed, that several conclusions were based solely on personal appreciation and not on scientific analysis, and that there was no evidence of planning, coordination or conspiracy between the two defendants in the case.
Likewise, they alluded to the fact that the eyewitnesses presented substantial contradictions and that the Public Prosecutor’s Office did not prove the element that both defendants acted in common and concerted agreement. Therefore, they requested a “peremptory acquittal judgment in favor of the accused” regarding all charges.
However, after evaluating the defense’s request, the judge issued a “no case.”
Cabrera Rivera’s sentencing is scheduled for September 10 at 10:00 am
Meanwhile, the judicial process against his daughter, Anthonieska Aviles Cabrerawho also faces two charges for the same crimes as his mother, is in the jury selection stage for the trial.
The day of the murder
The events occurred on the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025when a brawl broke out in the Roberto Colon detour. In the middle of the incident, Pratts Rosario, nicknamed “Lela,” was wounded 11 times with a knife. Likewise, Pratts Rosario’s best friend was stabbed.
Both victims were transported in separate vehicles to Menonita Hospital. There, at 12:35 am on Monday, August 11, 2025, Dr. Carla Mercado certified the death of Pratts Rosario. In contrast, the other minor recovered from the wound received in the back of the neck.
At the moment, the weapon used to commit the crime has not been seized by the authorities.
