Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
Aibonito – The jury trial against Elvia Cabrera Riveraaccused of the murder of the teenager Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosariocontinued this Wednesday on its nineteenth day, marked by the presentation of shocking messages and audios that show the tension that was unleashed after the crime.
The messages were extracted from the cell phone that Miriathny D. Aviles Rodriguez18 years old, voluntarily surrendered to the Homicide Division of the Criminal Investigation Corps (CIC) of Aibonito. The young woman is half-sister of Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraco-defendant in the case and daughter of Cabrera Rivera.
Under oath in Room 1 of the Aibonite CourtAviles Rodriguez, who is the 16th witness called to testify by the Public Ministry, confirmed that the sequence of messages is part of conversations she had with five close people, in a period of 12 hours, on August 11, 2025.
The exchange of messages was with his partner Karelin Plata Diaz, identified as “Mi life” in her telephone contacts; his partner’s friend, Giselys Rivera; his brothers Alan and Anthony; and an aunt, named “Aunt Mara” on her cell phone, testified to questions from prosecutor Silda Rubio Barreto at the Judicial Center.
“The truth is, now one is realizing Antho, Gaba and Anthiany, man…, and it’s not because now I’m going to join up with the Faviola combo, no. I stay alone, I better stay alone, I resolve my things alone, I testify alone and what I did see, not because of anyone’s battery, and I’m alone, because, man…, this, Antho was caught and you’re so unfortunate that you two aren’t. I, being Antho’s sister, they already caught my sister, I couldn’t wait for them to catch her, right now I’m ready to go, they didn’t even have to look for me But, crazy, if they caught my sister and my daughter too, hello. Elvia, ta’ cab…”, the witness was heard saying in one of the audios.
1/8 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
In another of the voice messages, which was also played out loud in the courtroom, before Judge Luis S. Barreto Altieri and the jury, Aviles Rodriguez adds: “It’s not saying the same thing, mommy, because it’s not lying or anything, because we don’t have to lie, we’re going to say what we saw, because your eyes saw the same thing as me, hello“You understand me, but nothing, calm down.”
Finally, in the third audio, the witness adds: “Damn…, they are my sisters and all, but this, devil, but they took her life. That’s not like that, do you understand me? I wouldn’t even have the heart either, man…, and to make matters worse, they come and leave the car there and you run away. Oh, no, that doesn’t apply to me. They are my sisters, I defended them to the death, but that’s it. That’s it. In a fight, well, I defend her. whoever has to defend, and blood is heavier than water, but maybe they killed her, no, not Elvia’s car and Elvia.”
Message exchange
According to the telephone record presented by the prosecutor, the first of those messages from Miriathny was sent at 11:40 am on August 11 to her partner. In it, she wrote: “And as for the murder, well, they were telling me that I am a murderer and it’s as if some idiot had killed her when it was with a knife and it wasn’t even me.”
Hours later, at 4:50 pm, he had a conversation with Giselys, a friend of his partner, in which he wrote: “They put me on TikTok.” At 4:59 pm he sent two consecutive messages: “And what about me?” “Look how lame…”, indicated the witness in the exchange of messages.
Later, at 5:02 pm, he wrote again: “What an embarrassment, but the truth will always come to light.” The witness explained that these messages emerged after a photograph of her began to circulate on social networks directly linking her to the crime.
At 6:30 pm he contacted the same person again to write: “People giving false information are on fire.” Shortly after, at 6:54 pm, he sent a message to his brother Alan in which he expressed: “I didn’t kill her, I gave in to despair.”
Later, at 7:08 pm, he sent Giselys: “Now they are putting things as they are.” However, thirty minutes later, at 7:38 pm, Aviles Rodriguez wrote to his partner: “They caught Antho.”
In keeping with the above, he sent his other brother, Anthony, a message that read: “They caught them already, I think.” In the courtroom he explained that with that expression he was referring to Cabrera Rivera and his half-sisters Anthonieska and Anthiany Aviles. Of them, only Cabrera Rivera and Anthonieska face charges for the crime.
The presentation of these messages and audios marked the morning of the nineteenth day of the trial, in which the Public Ministry continued to use digital evidence to reconstruct the hours after the murder and the reaction of one of the central witnesses in the case.
He saw his half-sister stab her
In his statements, Aviles Rodriguez insisted that he saw his half-sister stab the victim with a sharp object in the hip area. He stated that the last act of violence that he observed on the night of Sunday, August 10, 2025, on the Roberto Colon detour, was “that of Antho against Gabriela Nicole.”
1 / 31 | 📷 In images: the evidence that has come to light in the case of Gabriela Nicole Pratts. A knife occupied in an area surrounding Elvia Cabrera’s residence in Aibonito. – Judiciary
Likewise, he said that he observed that his half-sister’s attack on the victim was “with a sharp object.” Instead, he acknowledged that he did not see Cabrera Rivera with a sharp object or handing something to his daughter. Nor did he observe her taking any object out of her purse, as other witnesses alleged to the authorities.
This was the closing of the testimony of a witness who last week revealed alleged undue pressure from the Public Ministry during her initial statement, which took place on September 2, 2025.
“While I was giving my statement on September 2 (2025), first, the prosecutor (of the Aibonito District, Ernesto) Quesada (Ojeda) threatened me that I am telling lies and that I have 99 years in prison,” said Aviles Rodriguez, before the astonished gaze of everyone present in the room.
“I was sitting on September 2 in the Aibonito Prosecutor’s Office and, while I was saying what had happened, the prosecutor (Brenda Liz Soto Santiago) told me to say it like a pen,” she added during an explosive revelation that could completely change the course of the notorious case.
