Even with up to 24 video cameras, Major Leagues They did not have an accurate image to prove that Michael Massey’s glove touched Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s left foot at second base during the Los Angeles victory. New York Yankees on Saturday.
Umpire Lance Barrett’s decision to keep the batter safe stood and awarded him the stolen base, while Alex Verdugo followed with an RBI single that gave the New York ninth the definitive lead in the victory (6-5 ) about the Kansas City Royals in their first game of the American League Division Series.
“They just said there was nothing clear and convincing to overturn him, and if they had declared him out, that decision would have stood as well,” Royals manager Matt Quatraro said Sunday.
In the first postseason game with at least five different leads, the score was 5-5 when Chisholm singled off Michael Lorenzen leading off the seventh. Chisholm stole the base, while Anthony Volpe struck out.
As Chisholm slid to second, his left foot touched the ground inches from the base, causing him to rise.
Second baseman Michael Massey then jumped to catch catcher Salvador Perez’s throw and appeared to throw Chisholm out.
After conferring by phone with Royals instant replay coordinator Bill Duplissea, Quatraro signaled for the video to be reviewed.
Chris Conroy, the referee at Rockefeller Center’s replay operations center, spent about two minutes reviewing a series of videos in rectangles on a large screen inches from him. Informed of Conroy’s decision, Barrett announced to the fans of the Yankee Stadium: “After review, the decision on the field stands. The runner is safe.”
Umpires ruled Jazz Chisholm Jr. safe here pic.twitter.com/29OveSMIZ7
— Talkin’ Baseball (@TalkinBaseball_) October 6, 2024
Quatraro, who was observing from the dugout of the Royals with his arms crossed, shook his head.
MLB replay regulations state that the umpire in the control room has three options: confirm, change, or “let the decision stand in the field due to a lack of clear and convincing evidence to change it.”
“It’s like a judicial system, right? “You have to be clear and convincing, and what does that mean?” said Quatraro. “Clearly, we are saying that there was evidence to overturn it. But we’re talking about a fraction of an inch at high speed and all that. “I understand how difficult that is for everyone involved.”
