We explain: Why is artificial intelligence one of the reasons for the strikes in Hollywood?

We explain: Why is artificial intelligence one of the reasons for the strikes in Hollywood?

LOS ANGELES — The artificial intelligence (AI) has been at the forefront of the labor struggles of Hollywood. Alongside more traditional disputes over pay models, benefits and job protections, AI is the hit-or-miss point in the breakdowns in contract negotiations that have led screenwriters’ and actors’ unions to go on strike.

Technology has pushed negotiations into uncharted territory, and the language used can sound utopian or dystopian depending on which side of the table.

Here’s a look at the demands from unions and their employers regarding AI:

Why is artificial intelligence so controversial?

As the technology to create without creators advances, star actors fear losing control of their lucrative images. Unknown actors fear being completely replaced. The writers fear they will have to share credit or lose it to the machines.

The proposed contracts that led to both strikes last just three years. Even at the seemingly breakneck pace at which AI moves, it’s highly unlikely that there will be a widespread displacement of writers or actors in that period. But unions and employers know that by giving in it can be hard to make up ground in a next contract.

Emerging versions of the technology have already seeped into nearly every part of filmmaking, being used to dejuvenate actors like Harrison Ford in the latest “Indiana Jones” movie or Mark Hamill in “The Mandalorian,” to generate abstract animated images of Samuel L. Jackson and a swirl of aliens in the intro to “Secret Invasion” on Disney+, and to give recommendations on Netflix.

All parties involved in the strikes recognize that the even more extensive use of technology is inevitable. That is why everyone seeks to establish legal and creative control.

Actor and screenwriter Johnathan McClain said the battle echoes automation fights in other industries, but he predicts many more to come as technology improves.

“It’s easy to marginalize what we do because it’s entertainment,” McClain said at rallies outside Warner Bros. studios. “And I understand that. But I feel like on some level we are, as far as this technology conversation goes, a bit like a canary in a coal mine. This is an important moment and we really have to take a decisive position.”

Actress Frances Fisher holds a sign reading “AI is not art” at a writers’ and actors’ rally outside Paramount Studios in Los Angeles. (Chris Pizzello)

artificial intelligence and actors

The discussions between the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) and Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers (AMPTP)which represents the employers, turned from a theoretical framework into a bitter battle that spilled over into the public when the strike broke out on July 13.

In a description widely shared by outraged actors on social media, SAG-AFTRA posted this characterization of the studios’ position on AI, which the AMPTP called a deliberate misrepresentation. “We want to be able to scan an artist’s background image, pay them half a day’s work, and then use an individual’s image for any purpose forever without their consent,” the union said. “We also want to be able to make changes to lead artists’ dialogue, and even create new scenes, without informed consent. And we want to be able to use someone’s images, likenesses, and performances to train new generative AI systems without consent or compensation.”

The AMPTP said in a response statement that its offers included an “artificial intelligence proposal that protects the digital images of artists, including a requirement for the consent of artists for the creation and use of digital replicas or digital alterations of a performance”.

SAG-AFTRA used similar language to describe what they wanted, emphasizing the need to protect “human-created work,” including alterations to an actor’s “voice, appearance, or performance.”

It may be appropriate that “voice” is first on that list. While many viewers still cringe at the visual avatars of actors like Hamill and Jackson, the hearing technology feels more advanced.

The voices of the late Anthony Bourdain and the late Andy Warhol have been recreated for recent documentaries. Union members who make their living doing voiceovers have taken notice.

The writers ask to appear in the credits

In writers’ contract talks, which broke down in early May, the Writers Guild of America said it would allow the use of AI, but only to the extent that it was a tool for them to use in their own work.

They would potentially be willing to shape stories with the help of AI software. But they do not want it to affect the credits that are essential for their prestige and salary.

The guild wants to prevent AI-generated raw dialogue or stories from being considered “literary material”, a term in their contracts for screenplays and other forms of storytelling that a screenwriter produces. This means they wouldn’t be competing with computers for credit, or for an original screenplay Oscar.

The writers also do not want those stories or dialogues to be considered “source material”their contractual language for novels, video games, or other works that writers can turn into screenplays.

The AMPTP said in a document outlining its position that writers “want to use this technology as part of their creative process, without changing the way credits are determined, which is complicated given that AI material cannot be copyrighted.”

The studies also emphasized that the writers’ previous contracts established that any “corporate or impersonal provider” of literature is not a screenwriter.

“Only a ‘person’ can be considered a writer,” said the AMPTP. “AI-generated material would not be eligible for writing credit.”

While this position could assuage writers’ concerns about sharing credit with the AI, it could also lead to no one getting credit when they “collaborate” with it.

Modern writing contracts, and who gets what credit, are already a mess that the guild often has to step in and sort out. Detailed legal language is used to determine which name is preceded by “written by,” which name comes before “story by,” or which name follows “of characters created by.”

Putting artificial intelligence into the mix threatens to turn each of those terms into an even more tangled tangle.

Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media
Kumneger Media is a News and Entertainment Website & Channel. Kumneger Media in addition to News and Entertainment it is the hub of Politics, Movies, Drama, Music, Comedy, Documentary and More!