:format(jpeg):focal(1222x1578:1232x1568)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/gfrmedia/ERMASTQ5KVGJLEUBLBZFAZIHFE.jpg)
A familiar aroma wafted through Believer Meats’ experimental kitchen this year when Research and Development chef Andres Voloschin spun strips of chicken created from cells.
Through the glass walls I could see the large tanks where the cells grow. Scientists, not farmers, produced this chicken. Some business owners, consumers and experts predict that much more of the world’s meat will be produced this way in the future.
More than 150 startups are pursuing an ambitious goal: meat that doesn’t require raising and killing animals, is affordable, and tastes and feels like the meat we eat now. They are part of a young industry that aims to use cellular biology to reduce the environmental impact of the world’s ever-increasing demand for meat, and change global protein production in the same way that electric cars are revolutionizing the industry. automotive.
“We are addicted to meat as a species. It is part of our evolution. “It’s part of our culture.” said Yaakov Nahmias, founder of Believer, whose country, Israel, is a hub of the industry along with California and Singapore. But “we think about quantity more than the environment, more than sustainability.”
Companies that produce so-called “cultured” meat – which is also popularly known as “lab-grown” meat – are trying to rapidly increase their operations by partnering with traditional meat companies, attracting more and more investors and starting the establishment of new ones. production facilities in the United States and elsewhere.
However, widespread adoption of cell-based meat is far from guaranteed. This meat is expensive to make. There are scientific challenges, such as learning to imitate the complex structure of the steak. Government regulation is another obstacle. Only Singapore and the United States allow the sale of cultured meat.
And although many people who have tried it say they like it, others find it an unpleasant idea. An Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research poll found that half of U.S. adults are unlikely to try it, a country hungry for meat. Most of those who said they wouldn’t do it stated that “it just sounds strange.”
Even Oren, Nahmias’ 10-year-old son, says he will only eat traditional meat. “I feel bad” for the animals, he said, “but they are delicious!”
How cells can turn into a cutlet
The science behind this new meat comes from the medical world. Nahmias, a bioengineer, launched his company after having lunch with a Tyson Foods executive at a conference and scribbling on a napkin his method for producing cultured meat.
Unlike traditional agriculture, this process begins with cells. Depending on the companycells can come from a piece of tissue, a fertilized egg, or a “bank” of cells. It is possible to use several types. Scientists choose cells that can self-renew and become muscle cells and fat cells that make up meat tissue. From initial cells they create “cell lines” so that they do not have to resort to animal lines again.
These cells are placed inside containers of various sizes called bioreactors and bathed in a nutrient-rich broth, in which they multiply. Thick, structured meat also requires a scaffold that helps the cells organize to take a certain shape. Changes in the composition of the broth or medium, and certain signals from the scaffold, tell the immature cells to become muscle, fat, or connective tissue.
Once the bioreactor is full at Believer, which is based in the Israeli city of Rehovot, the cell paste is collected and mixed with plant proteins, then pressurized and ejected to create meat fibers, Nahmias explained.
Now Believer produces cultured chicken and lamb and has plans for beef, which is more complicated to produce because it is more difficult to create genetically stable cell lines from larger animals.
Still, other companies are trying to produce cultured beef. It is the target of Aleph Farms – which competes with Believer and is also located in Rehovot – where a scientist has scribbled a cow’s face on laboratory equipment. Their product cell line began from a fertilized egg from a Black Angus cow named Lucy living on a California farm.
Producing meat in this way could also dramatically reduce the impact of meat on the environment, because it would reduce the need to set aside land for animals and their food. Various studies show that traditional livestock production is responsible for between 10% and 20% of greenhouse gas emissions.
“The most important thing is that this field advances and begins to reduce the destruction of our environment linked to current animal agriculture techniques,” said Glenn Gaudette, a biomedical engineering specialist at Boston College.
It’s not that easy to assemble a steak
But transforming the ecosystem is a vision that is still distant. At present, companies are still perfecting their products.
Scientists and industry experts say cultured meats have a long way to go before they are indistinguishable from conventional meats.especially when it comes to the texture of products other than hamburger meat or nuggets.
“When I buy a steak, I want to see a steak,” said Jon Medved, CEO of OurCrowd, an Israeli investment platform. “And we’re just not there yet.”
Price is also a problem. Production costs for the first cultured meat burger, created a decade ago by Mark Post at Maastricht University in the Netherlands, were estimated at hundreds of thousands of dollars. Now, the university says, the company he helped found, Mosa Meat, has reduced that amount to about $10 as it works toward commercialization.
For cultured meat to take hold, these trends must continue, said Bruce Friedrich, president and founder of the Good Food Institute, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit advocacy group focused on cultured and plant-based proteins. “If we don’t have products that taste the same or better and cost the same or less, people are not going to make the change” to acquire them, he declared.
But there are perplexing scientific obstacles. Gaudette said scientists are still trying to find the best scaffolds for structured meat, which must include a way for oxygen to reach all the cells. Options include animal-based structures such as gelatin and, increasingly, decellularized vegetables such as spinach.
Gaudette said scientists are also working on challenges like getting the cells to adhere to the scaffolds and align in the right way.
Feeding the cells, the most expensive part of the cultured meat process, presents different dilemmas. Some media include fetal bovine serum, which is expensive and is derived from the blood of a cow fetus. Other types do not contain whey, but include expensive ingredients. Startups are exploring less expensive non-animal alternatives, such as food-grade, rather than pharmaceutical-grade, “growth factors” – substances that stimulate cells to divide and grow in number.
Experts hope scientists will overcome the remaining obstacles. But they say shaping human perception could be more difficult.
Lab-grown meat sounds strange
Most people associate meat production with farms rather than scientific laboratories, which influences how they perceive these new products.
In the AP-NORC poll, only 18% of American adults said they are extremely or very likely to try cultured meat, and 30% said they are likely. Those under 45 are more likely to try it than older adults, and men are more likely to try it than women. When those who wouldn’t try it were asked to choose why from a list of reasons, half said they didn’t think it was safe.
That’s a concern for respondent Nora Bailey, 31, a mother of three in rural Arkansas.
“Obviously I would like to do more research into the long-term effects,” since it could happen that the first products, which were initially considered safe, could later be found not to be safe, he said.
A World Health Organization report highlighted several potential safety problems, such as microbial contamination at various points in the process, biological byproducts and scaffolds that some people may be allergic to.
Experts acknowledged that much more safety testing is needed, but noted that conventional meat carries significant food safety risks, such as possible bacterial contamination during slaughter.
At this point, relatively few people have tried cultured meat. But since its approval in the United States this summer, a small number of diners are eating it for the first time at certain restaurants and at special events.
People who recently tried chicken grown at the headquarters of the American company Good Meat, in Alameda, California, said they liked it and would eat it again. “When I bit into it, it was juicy. It wasn’t dry. It did have that kind of chicken feel and flavor,” said Karen Hunt, who participated in the taste test because she works nearby. “I was pleasantly surprised, and it tasted delicious.”
He said he doesn’t mind the way it’s made, especially when he thinks about how traditional chicken is produced. The cultured meat process seems clean, controlled, environmentally safe and more humanehe declared.
Kenzo Khoo, a nutritional sciences student at the University of California, Berkeley campus, said he would eat it regularly instead of traditional chicken if it became just as affordable.
“I would definitely buy it knowing that it will be more sustainable… because I think climate change really is a big problem,” he said after trying it. “Personally, I don’t perceive any kind of difference.”
When will it be widely available?
Experts say many more people will try cultured meat soon. A recent report from the Good Food Institute found that investments in cultured meat tripled on average each year from 2016 to 2022. About 70 traditional meat and food companies are involved in some way with cultured meat. And regulatory approvals in the United States are expected to be followed by many more elsewhere.
With all that driving them forward, some cultured meat companies are growing as fast as their cells. Good Meat has nearly completed a production facility in Singapore and plans a full-scale plant in the United States. Believer broke ground on its own large-scale plant in North Carolina last December.
Global strategic consulting firm McKinsey & Company predicts that cultured meat could provide billions of kilograms of the world’s meat supply by 2030. However, that’s only about 0.5%, and nowhere near enough to offset the growing consumption of animal meat.
While no one expects cultured meat to transform human diets anytime soon, some experts say demographic and climate pressures could make traditional meat production impossible in the long term, making cultured meat a potential solution. for a fragile and growing world.
