Editor’s note: visit this special place to consult all the content of the coverage of the Gabriela Nicole case.
He Court of Appeals rejected the defense’s request Anthonieska Aviles Cabreraco-accused of the murder of the minor Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, 16 years old, that sought to postpone the jury trial for a reasonable minimum period of six months, alleging that the intense media coverage of the case had affected the possibility of selecting an impartial jury.
In an eight-page ruling issued Wednesday, a Court of Appeals panel of judges Juan R. Hernandez Sanchez, Waldemar Rivera Torres and Ricardo G. Marrero Guerrerodetermined not to intervene in the petition presented by the Legal Aid Society (SALT).
“We do not identify any reason why this forum should intervene,” The panel indicated the decision in the document.
As part of their arguments, Aviles Cabrera’s defense alleged that, from the day after the events, which occurred in August 2025, the case received unprecedented media coverage, motivated by an initial version of what happened that, according to their lawyers, had not been supported with evidence.
Likewise, the SAL pointed out that this coverage provoked widespread public rejection, expressions of condemnation by government officials and strong pressure to arrest and prosecute the people identified as suspects in the crime that occurred in the middle of a brawl on the Roberto Colon bypass.
He maintained that, during the following days, the secretary of the Department of Justice, Lourdes Gomez Torresand the superintendent of the Police, Joseph Gonzalezmade public statements identifying the suspects before the charges were filed.
Likewise, the defense stated that, after the presentation of the complaints against the accused, both were exposed to the media before and after the hearing to determine probable cause for arrest and later transferred to the correctional complex for failing to provide the required bail.
He maintained that, although the accused was 17 years old at the time of the events and has an intellectual disability certified by the Department of Educationhis identity and his image were publicly disseminated. They stated that this exposure led to a wave of harassment, ridicule and threats on social networks.which motivated correctional authorities to establish special security measures.
Likewise, the legal representation of the accused stated that the Supreme Court authorized the transmission of several stages of the process despite the opposition of the defense and in violation of the Regulations of the Experimental Program for the Use of Photographic Cameras and Audiovisual Broadcasting Equipment by the Media in Judicial Processes (PECAM).
In his appeal, The defense alleged that extensive media coverage of the case compromised their right to a fair and impartial trial.. He argued that, although he is not part of the trial against his mother and co-defendant, Elvia Cabrera Rivera, The evidence presented in that process has been widely disseminated and publicly discussed, which, in his opinion, contaminated the potential jurors..
1/8 | In photos: the sheets with messages that have marked the case of Gabriela Nicole. In the middle of the trial for the murder of Gabriela Nicole Pratts Rosario, there have been several occasions in which a sheet with a message has been spread on the Aibonito Panoramic Route, on the way to the court. – Alex Figueroa Cancel
Likewise, he maintained that “The media and commentators discussed the evidence presented daily, and even published photographs and accusations related to it”so they understand that their constitutional rights to freedom had been affected. “presumption of innocence and a fair and impartial trial”.
Likewise, they alleged that during the investigation controversies arose related to the delivery of exculpatory evidence, stating that notes from the investigative agent Angel Torres Romero They revealed the existence of other possible suspects, contrary to the initial position of the Public Ministry.
Therefore, the defense requested that the trial be postponed for at least six months after the conclusion of the judicial process against his mother. Both defendants face two counts of first-degree murder and violation of the Weapons Law for use and/or possession of a knife.
However, both the Aibonito Court and the Court of Appeals rejected that approach. By denying the appeal, the panel concluded that the defense “has not demonstrated” that the Aibonito Court had acted arbitrarily.would incur a “gross abuse of discretion” or committed a legal error that justified its intervention.
When hearing the appeal, the Court of Appeals examined whether it was appropriate to intervene under the criteria established in Rule 40 of its Regulations, which governs the issuance of writs of arrest. certiorari and other orders.
“After examining the file before our consideration, in light of the criteria of Rule 40 of the Rules of the Court of Appeals, supra, we do not identify any reason why this forum should intervene. This, since none of the situations contemplated therein arise,” the secondary forum noted.
“Let us remember that our legal system gives us the discretion to intervene in those interlocutory rulings in which the Court of First Instance has been arbitrary, committed a gross abuse of discretion or when, from the actions of the forum, an error arises in the interpretation or application of any procedural rule or substantive law. We reiterate that in the resource we are dealing with here we have not been shown that there are any of these scenarios.”, stated the Appellate.
With this decision, the judicial process against Aviles Cabrera, who is now 18 years old, will continue its course in the Aibonito Court, with the selection of the jury members who will have the responsibility of evaluating the evidence presented in the trial.
Meanwhile, the trial against his mother entered a climactic stage with the last witnesses of the Public Ministry.
