Workers began emergency repairs Tuesday afternoon to stabilize a Manhattan building, New Yorkafter deformed columns and collapsed floors forced the evacuation of construction and nearby properties in the Midtown sector.
The emergency developed throughout the day, after structural problems were detected in the morning in the building, built in the 1970s and currently in the process of being converted into luxury apartments. The workers and people who were in nearby buildings, including a school, diplomatic offices and several hotels, were quickly evacuated after a call to the firefighters around 8:00 am
In the early afternoon, the mayor of New York, Zohran Mamdanistated that the building remained unstable and described the situation as “extremely serious.”
After inspecting the structure floor by floor, municipal authorities determined that the damaged columns no longer showed additional movements, which allowed contractors to be authorized to begin emergency repairs, the mayor’s office reported. During the afternoon, workers were observed reinforcing the affected areas within the glass and steel building.
1 / 14 | Images of the emergency: a building in the heart of New York is evacuated due to possible collapse. An office skyscraper, which was formerly the headquarters of the pharmaceutical company Pfizer, was evacuated due to fear of a possible collapse of the structure. -Angelina Katsanis
The temporary measures seek to stabilize the structure and the work is expected to last for several days, which will continue to affect the area near Grand Central Station, one of Manhattan’s main transportation hubs.
Fire Department and Buildings Department officials said they were continuing to inspect neighboring properties to determine when evacuation orders could be lifted and closed streets reopened. By late afternoon, some residents were allowed to return to their homes.
Fear of collapse motivated evacuations
The building, former headquarters of the pharmaceutical company Pfizer, is located a short walk from iconic New York landmarks, such as the Chrysler Building and the United Nations headquarters.
Leila Bozorg, the city’s vice mayor, said it was “encouraging” that the building did not appear to continue moving as inspectors toured the affected floors until they reached the 37th floor, the top of the structure.
From the street, a severely deformed structural column could be seen through a window on the 21st floor. The Fire Department also released images of that column and reported that it detected multiple cracks and sinkholes in the floors.
Asked about the risk of a collapse, Fire Department Chief John Esposito explained that, due to the steel structure of the building, “it would not be a total collapse, but rather a localized collapse.”
Nearby buildings and streets remained evacuated for much of the day, including a school and the Israeli consulate, located in front of the building. The former Pfizer headquarters was unoccupied except for construction workers.
Ramesh Yallappa, a tourist evacuated from a nearby hotel, said he initially thought it was a fire.
“At that moment we were very, very scared,” he said.
Developer attributes the damage to the expansion of the building
With more than 1,600 apartments planned, developers say the project represents the largest conversion of offices into housing in New York history. The Gensler architecture firm indicated that the work contemplates the transformation of two office buildings from the 1970s, through the construction of more than a dozen additional floors and the redesign of an adjacent tower.
Department of Buildings records show the project had received several penalties for safety violations, including falling glass and metal parts, as well as an accident in which a worker fell from a ladder.
Spokespeople for Gensler and developer MetroLoft did not respond to requests for comment.
However, in statements to The New York Times, MetroLoft maintained that the building is not in danger of collapsing and that no debris fell from the structure.
Nathan Berman, founder of MetroLoft, told The Wall Street Journal that the additional weight generated by the expansion of approximately 15 upper floors likely caused the damage. As he explained, it is possible that the two deformed columns had not been adequately reinforced.
“Why precisely those two columns and no others? We don’t know,” Berman said. “We are investigating it.”
He also assured that the overall integrity of the building had not been compromised.
“95% of the building is in good condition and intact,” he said. “There is no way that this corner of a small addition would cause the building to suddenly collapse.”
Experts foresee more extensive repairs
Emily Guglielmo, a structural engineer, said the deformed columns will likely need to be removed and replaced.
“Many of these things, such as cracks, deformations and sinking, are probably no longer repairable,” he said.
Specialists consulted agreed that replacing the columns will require detailed analysis and costly repairs.
“The immediate solution is to shore up the structure and the floors,” explained Abi Aghayere, a professor of structural engineering at Drexel University.
Shoring involves installing temporary structures that support the load of the building until the columns can be replaced.
Yi Bao, an associate professor of civil engineering at Stevens Institute of Technology, warned that the damage could extend beyond the deformed columns, forcing loads to be redistributed to other parts of the building.
Ed Miller, a resident of the area, commented that he usually passes in front of the building several times a day, although now he will look for another route to return home.
“The building was pretty old,” said Miles Grant, who worked there previously. “It certainly needed a lot of renovations to become a residential building.”
