Democracy in the United States: What We’ll Be Watching in 2025

Democracy in the United States: What We’ll Be Watching in 2025

Regardless of the elections’ outcome, Freedom House will continue to highlight urgent challenges to American democracy and their underlying causes.

With the United States facing closely contested general elections, Freedom House has been highlighting potential democratic risks surrounding the process—from harassment of poll workers, to postelection efforts to impede certification of the vote, to political violence—and promoting important ways to mitigate those risks.

But as an organization that has been assessing political rights and civil liberties in more than 200 countries and territories for over a half century, we’re also looking beyond the elections and at the larger story of America’s democratic decline. Over the last 13 years, the United States has fallen by 11 points in our 100-point Freedom in the World index, now placing far behind long-standing democratic nations that had previously been our peers. The signs of erosion are many: worsening congressional gridlock, declining trust in democratic institutions, and the assault on our democracy on January 6, 2021, among them. The causes are complex and systemic, and include deepening political polarization, persistent inequality, and a rapidly changing media environment.

Regardless of the coming elections’ results, Freedom House will continue to assess the United States along with the rest of the world, and advocate for protecting rights and safeguarding and renewing our democracy. We have done so as part of our fierce commitment to the nonpartisan defense of freedom and democracy globally for more than 80 years, including denouncing the excesses of McCarthyism at home while combatting communism abroad, and condemning Jim Crow–era racial segregation, Watergate-era abuses of power, and efforts to overturn the 2020 election. We will continue to do so, without fear or favor.

Challenges to US democracy that we’ll be monitoring include the following.

Fewer constraints on executive power

The Supreme Court’s decision in Trump v. United States established a broad new regime of presidential immunity from criminal liability. As we noted after the decision, the new immunity rules go well beyond the typical protections for leaders in other democracies by providing absolute immunity for a potentially broad range of presidential actions. In doing so, they undermine a key deterrent against a range of criminal abuses of office—such as corruption and fraud—that every other public office holder rightly faces.

The decision could also lead to the broader degradation of congressional and judicial checks on presidential power, given the court’s expansive reading of presidential “core powers” that cannot be constrained by the other two branches of government. It is not clear, for example, whether Congress is now more constrained than before in using its legislative and oversight powers to ensure accountability at federal agencies like the Departments of Justice or Defense.

Further, the decision appears to have removed a key deterrent against a president’s influencing, or even directing, individual Justice Department investigations and prosecutions. This could enable future presidents to more easily target their perceived political opponents with criminal scrutiny—just as former president Trump attempted to do at least a dozen times, and has pledged to do again if elected.